The debate over TransCanada’s proposed oil pipeline from the oil sands of Alberta to the Texas Gulf Coast has mostly focused on the environmental and economic impacts. People in favor say it will bring jobs and energy security. Opponents say the pipeline, and the crude it will carry, will harm the earth.
But the project might have another consequence that’s been largely overlooked. Some analysts say it could actually raise gas prices for many American consumers.
Access to crude oil is not evenly distributed. There are large sections of the country that are awash in the stuff and others that have little. These days the upper region of the American Midwest has more crude from Canada, North Dakota and Montana than refineries can handle. And a huge glut of oil called West Texas Intermediate is sitting in Oklahoma, undervalued because it can’t get to refineries.
In effect, that’s exactly what the Keystone XL Pipeline would accomplish.
Like the pipeline’s other supporters, Prescott says bringing that crude to refineries will increase supply and translate into lower gas prices for consumers. It’s basic supply and demand, he says. But in the world of international oil markets, things aren’t always simple. And some experts warn that moving Canadian crude to Texas will actually drive prices up where consumers benefit from over-supply.
These Deals Won’t Last ForeverPhillip Verleger runs the Energy Consulting firm PK Verleger. Recently he’s lead the charge against the pipeline proposal not from an environmental standpoint, but because he believes it would actually be bad for the U.S. oil industry.
“Proponents of the Canadian pipeline testified to the Canadian energy board, that Keystone would extract an extra six billion dollars from the upper Midwest,” he told StateImpact Texas.
He says if TransCanada’s pipeline from Alberta is completed, “what you would have is consumers in Illinois, Minnesota, probably Iowa Nebraska, possibly Missouri and possibly the Dakotas paying more.”
Others say the same could happen with the glut of oil in Oklahoma.
A Real Punch in the Glut
Like Canadian crude to the North, West Texas Intermediate crude in Cushing, Oklahoma is selling cheaper because it can’t get to refineries. The southern leg of the Keystone pipeline, and another project by the Enbridge pipeline company is set to bring that crude to the Gulf.
“That’s the concern here. Is that by removing the glut in supply that you will cause oil prices to go up which will likely impact motorists,” Patrick Dahaan, an analyst for GasBuddy.Com told StateImpact Texas.
Dahaan says it’s possible that a jump in the price of West Texas Intermediate, which is used as a benchmark in oil pricing by investors, could lead to higher gas prices in states like Oklahoma and Texas.
TransCanada’s Precott disagrees with both Verleger and Dahaan, and emailed a Department of Energy memo from June of last year to back up his position.
“It says in the summary and conclusion that these pipeline projects would not increase gasoline prices to Midwestern consumers. That’s the last line in the report,” he paraphrased.
But some of the oil companies set to refine crude from TransCanada’s pipeline, concede that it could raise prices in some places.
“I suppose it’s possible that places like the Rocky Mountains could see a slight increase in prices. The benefit to the rest of the country is going to outweigh that though.” Bill Day, spokesman for Valero, told StateImpact Texas.
Day says more crude flowing South to the Gulf should lower oil prices on the East coast and other parts of the country, offsetting any rise in the mid-continent.
Good news if you’re a driver in Boston, but probably cold comfort if you’re currently paying lower prices for gas because of the abundance of crude in your neck of the woods.