PUC Approves Higher Prices for Wholesale Electricity

Courtesy PUC

PUC's Donna Nelson

This morning Public Utility Commission Chair Donna Nelson and Commissioner Rolando Pablos voted to approve an increase in the price cap for wholesale electricity in Texas. Commissioner  Kenneth Anderson, Jr. abstained.

Before today’s vote, the wholesale price of electricity had been capped at $3,000 per megawatt hour. Under the new rule that will rise to $4,500.  It’s meant to make the business of selling power in Texas more profitable. Supporters say that’s necessary to encourage investment in new power plants.

“We don’t require the building of generation in Texas. We set up the market forces so that generators want to come to Texas,” PUC Chair Donna Nelson told StateImpact Texas after the vote.

Commissioner Anderson, the one abstaining vote, had long been skeptical of raising the cap this year. Before the vote he argued again that the price hike would not impact power plant construction by the end of the summer.

“I’m just not convinced, as I wasn’t back in April, that it was necessary to do it for this summer. My preference was, and in the end remains that market participants, particularly load serving entities, need more time to adjust to this change.”

In April, Anderson had said power companies would be “carting money away not in wheel barrows, but in Mack trucks,” if the vote was approved this summer.

The move is part of an effort to get companies to build more power plants at a time when officials worry the Texas may not have enough electricity to avoid rolling blackouts in long term. But some groups worry that the price hike could mean higher electric rates for consumers.

“No one knows how much this will cost Texas,” said Texas Coalition for Affordable Power Board President Jay Doegey, “or even whether it will result in more generation coming online. But one outcome seems likely: Texas consumers will end up paying more.”

Right now, there is no comprehensive analysis of consumer impact, and the estimates that exist have varied widely– from a two percent hike per household to an increase amounting to $200 for every person in Texas.

This post has been updated with added reaction. StateImpact Texas intern Robb Jacobson contributed reporting to this article.

Comments

  • neilmoyer

    Why is the Chair smiling??  Oh, right, TX PUC works for the electricity generators, not consumers.  Massive windfall for generators firing up old natural gas-fired units.  ERCOT fails again, with complicity from TX PUC!  Hang’em high!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Johnny-White/100002978272355 Johnny White

    Donna Nelson does not respect the basics of Economic Theory.  Nor does she appreciate that “electricity de-regulation” in Texas has been a dismal failure for the consumer. Compare the consistantly lower electric pricing for customers of the “regulated” municipally owned electric power utility in Austin, Texas.  Treating electricity like it is a “commodity” to be traded on the open markets for profit is WRONG for consumers because it typically inflates the final cost.. 

    The current position of the PUC incentivizes market manipulation and artificial power shortages for extraordinary profits. It does NOT encourage the voluntary increase in generating capacity. Regualted electricity markets in the USA have historically produced some of the lowest electric rates in the entire world – for several generations! 

    Thanks to George W. Bush and the corrupt GOP (and their cronies like former crooks Enron and Ken Lay  and  current Governor Rick Perry and his PUC commissioners) Texas consumers get the royal shaft in electric pricing and reliability with no real solution in sight.

    • Pete Houston

       In 2009 we were paying .10/kw.  Today we are paying .0587/kw.  Competition between the power providers has reduced the cost to my business by 40% and we have hired workers and bought equipment.  The service that I get from Centerpoint has not changed but I have changed power providers.  The price of power from natural gas has dropped substantially for generator.  A 7 heat rate power plant times $2.5 natural gas equals a cost of production of a mw to $22.  That means that they can put the kw on the grid for .022/kw.  Yes they have some cost for construction and operations.  So with all that being said, I believe that competition within texas has been a good thing. 

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Education