Pennsylvania

Energy. Environment. Economy.

Topics

Liquefied natural gas pipes run under the loading pier and along a mile long tunnel under the Chesapeake Bay to the onshore facility at Cove Point, Md.

LNG exports: Marcellus Shale goes global

Background

LNG stands for liquified natural gas. In order to transport large amounts of natural gas, it must be cooled to the point where it becomes a liquid.

Not too long ago, when it came to LNG, the talk centered on import terminals. But all that has changed thanks to fracking for shale gas in places like Pennsylvania and Texas.

In 2012, the Department of Energy released its long-awaited report on liquefied natural gas exports. The “Macroeconomic Impacts of LNG Exports from the United States” gave an enthusiastic thumbs-up to sending U.S. natural gas overseas.

The authors of the DOE report say in all the market scenarios examined, LNG exports resulted in a net economic gain.

“In all of these cases, benefits that come from export expansion more than outweigh the losses from reduced capital and wage income to U.S. consumers, and hence LNG exports have net economic benefits in spite of higher domestic natural gas prices. This is exactly the outcome that economic theory describes when barriers to trade are removed.”

The U.S. currently has two export terminals, one in Sabine Pass, Louisiana, and the ConocoPhillips LNG export terminal in North Cook Inlet, Alaska. The DOE recently gave its preliminary approval for Dominion Resources to retrofit its Cove Point, Maryland import terminal to export liquefied natural gas. The facility is already connected to an interstate pipeline system that would bring gas straight from Marcellus Shale wells in Pennsylvania. About 16 other export proposals now await approval by the DOE.

The Winners

The push for exports makes sense for producers who have become the victims of their own success. U.S. Natural gas prices have plummeted in recent years due to increased production in gas plays like the Marcellus Shale. The price of natural gas in the U.S. now hovers around $3.50 per million British thermal units. But in Europe that same amount of gas fetches more than $10. So exports would help producers by reducing domestic supply and increasing prices. The report, conducted for the DOE by the economic consulting firm NERA, says exports make sense as long as there’s a glut of natural gas with low production costs in the U.S. and a high demand overseas. The study concludes that new LNG export terminals would result in just slight increases in the price of natural gas.

“Natural gas price changes attributable to LNG exports remain in a relatively narrow range across the entire range of scenarios. Natural gas price increases at the time LNG exports could begin range from zero to $0.33 (2010$/Mcf). The largest price increases that would be observed after 5 more years of potentially growing exports could range from $0.22 to $1.11 (2010$/Mcf). The higher end of the range is reached only under conditions of ample U.S. supplies and low domestic natural gas prices, with smaller price increases when U.S. supplies are more costly and domestic prices higher.”

The report’s authors point out that even with the highest price jump, natural gas remains much cheaper than oil. This is good news for producers, pipeline companies that would transport the gas to the export terminals, and those who invest in these companies.

The Losers

But the DOE report does say LNG exports will depress real wages, due to increased costs in fuel.

  ”Households with income solely from wages or government transfers, in particular, might not participate in these benefits.”

So not everyone has rallied behind this report. Manufacturers in particular, have seen a resurgence with the low price of natural gas in the U.S., both as a feedstock for plastics, and as a cheaper fuel. George Biltz, a former vice president for Dow Chemical, told StateImpact Pennsylvania that shale gas has transformed the petrochemical industry.

“It’s a massive competitive advantage for this industry,” said Blitz.

Biltz says in the late 1990s the U.S. started to run out of cheap natural gas. Prices that were once about $3.50 per million British thermal units, jumped as high as $14 before 2008. Since natural gas liquids are the raw materials for plastics, and the largest cost to a manufacturer, a lot of those industries left the U.S. But Biltz says those jobs are coming back thanks to cheap natural gas. Dow Chemical criticized the DOE’s study as “flawed.”

“The report issued by the DOE on liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports is flawed, misleading, and based on outdated, inaccurate and incomplete economic data,” said DOW CEO Andrew N. Liveris in a press release. “The report fails to give due consideration to the importance of manufacturing to the U.S. economy. Manufacturing is the largest user of natural gas in the U.S., and creates more jobs and more value to the U.S. economy from natural gas than any other sector.”

Liveris is leading the charge against LNG exports and founded a lobbying group called America’s Energy Advantage to promote keeping natural gas at home.

Latest Posts

EIA projects higher natural gas prices and production in 2017

U.S. natural gas prices are expected to rise in 2017 on growing domestic consumption, increased pipeline exports to Mexico, and more exports of liquefied natural gas, the U.S. Energy Information Administration said in its Short-Term Energy Outlook Tuesday. The agency, part of the federal Department of Energy, predicted the spot price of natural gas will rise [...]

Federal court rules FERC doesn’t have to review upstream impacts of LNG

The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled this week that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is not required to examine the upstream impacts of natural gas development when reviewing the environmental impacts of new liquefied natural gas export facilities under the National Environmental Policy Act. Instead, the court said that if any agency should examine [...]

Federal appeals court hears arguments over LNG exports

The battle over Dominion Energy’s Cove Point liquefied natural gas export terminal in Lusby, MD, is now in the hands of a federal appeals court, even as construction on the facility continues. The D.C. circuit court of appeals heard oral arguments from attorneys representing environmentalists, industry and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) on Thursday [...]

How the Trans-Pacific Partnership could impact LNG exports

The U.S. has negotiated a trade deal with 11 countries that has environmentalists worried about more liquefied natural gas exports. The Trans-Pacific Partnership looks to remove trade barriers with Asia. And Asia, specifically Japan, is eager for more natural gas from the United States. If the agreement gets through Congress, it would remove the role [...]

Environmentalists sue FERC over Cove Point LNG project

Environmental groups filed a lawsuit in federal court today challenging the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s decision to approve Dominion Energy’s Cove Point LNG export terminal in Lusby, MD. FERC had granted approval to the $3.8 billion project back in September, and construction on expanding the idled import terminal into an export terminal began in October. [...]

FERC rejects environmentalists appeal on Cove Point LNG exports

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has denied a request by several environmental groups to halt construction on Dominion Energy’s Cove Point LNG export terminal in Lusby, MD and conduct a more thorough environmental review. Environmentalists have been fighting the conversion of the mothballed import terminal into an import/export facility, saying FERC should consider the environmental [...]

Gas industry urges U.S. to speed approval of LNG export terminals

The natural gas industry’s leading trade group on Thursday stepped up pressure on the federal government to approve plans for liquefied natural gas export terminals, issuing a white paper which argues that the U.S. risks missing an opportunity to dominate the global market unless it acts quickly. America’s Natural Gas Alliance said the U.S. could [...]

With shale boom, U.S. expected to become net energy exporter

Reversing a trend that has lasted more than half a century, the federal government predicts the U.S. will become a net energy exporter within 15 years, as the shale boom increases the production of crude oil and natural gas. In its Annual Energy Outlook, the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) says advanced technologies are reshaping [...]

Amid lower oil prices, Moody’s predicts failure of many gas export projects

Lower global oil prices, coupled with new gas supplies in Australia will cause the cancellation of most liquefied natural gas (LNG) export projects planned for the U.S. and Canada, according to a new report from Moody’s Investors Services. Moody’s expects several projects already under construction will go forward as planned and be successful. That list includes [...]

Shale bubble burst on the horizon? New report questions government’s rosy forecast

Marcellus Shale production could peak in just five years, plateau, and then tail off quickly, according to new research by a team of petroleum engineers at the University of Texas. The UT forecast is significantly less optimistic than recent reports issued by the Energy Information Administration, a government agency. The research is reported today in [...]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Economy
Education