Utility terminations resumed April 1, 2021.
Allyson Ruggieri / WESA
Measures to preserve ‘energy choice’ gaining momentum in legislature
Opponents say the bills would lock in status quo for fossil fuels
-
Rachel McDevitt
Allyson Ruggieri / WESA
Utility terminations resumed April 1, 2021.
Updated: 2021-11-05 14:15:24
Measures claiming to promote âenergy choiceâ in Pennsylvania appear to be gaining momentum in the legislature.
Senate Bill 275, which would prohibit municipalities from restricting access to a certain utility, such as natural gas or solar, passed the state Senate at the end of last month. A companion bill, House Bill 1947 cleared a committee vote the same week.
The proposals are similar to laws passed in 20 states in the last two years and part of a larger trend of states trying to get ahead of local efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions.
Backers say it will ensure energy affordability and reliability.
But critics say it will lock in the status quo for fossil fuels.
âIt is not offering consumers any additional energy choices, it is simply saying the choices you have now are what you are going to have indefinitely.â said Robert Routh, an attorney with Clean Air Council. âItâs about trying to block a conversation, an important conversation, that should be happening at the local level before itâs even begun.â
According to state data, 12 percent of the commonwealthâs greenhouse gas emissions come from burning fossil fuels for uses such as heating and cooking in homes and businesses. For large cities, buildings account for a larger share of the overall emissions. One strategy to tackle that is to mandate all-electric construction for new buildings and make plans to retrofit older buildings.
While some places such as New York City and Chicago have committed to electrification plans, Amy Sturges, director of governmental affairs for the Pennsylvania Municipal League, said she hasnât heard of any community in Pennsylvania working on a mandate.
Sturges said the bills in the legislature donât seem to be written specifically for Pennsylvania. She said local governments here already canât issue mandates on utilities, because those are regulated by the Pennsylvania Utility Commission, so she questions the real purpose of the bill.
NPR has reported gas utilities and trade groups have lobbied to pass similar utility ban preemption bills across the country.
The Municipal League, a nonpartisan nonprofit that represents local governments, is concerned about broad language used in the measures, which also prohibits discrimination against utility service providers.
Sturges said some communities are working on climate action plans that may offer incentives for clean energy use in the future.
âThey should be able to promote non-mandated actions without fear of exposure to legal battles,â she said.
Pa. Republican lawmakers and the U.S. Capitol attack
As part of WITFâs commitment to standing with facts, and because the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol was an attempt to overthrow representative democracy in America, we are marking elected officialsâ connections to the insurrection. Read more about this commitment.
Sen. Gene Yaw (R-Lycoming) signed a letter asking members of Congress to delay certifying Pennsylvaniaâs electoral votes despite no evidence that would call those results into question. The election-fraud lie led to the attack on the Capitol.
As part of WITFâs commitment to standing with facts, and because the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol was an attempt to overthrow representative democracy in America, we are marking elected officialsâ connections to the insurrection. Read more about this commitment.
Sen. Gene Yaw (R-Lycoming) signed a letter asking members of Congress to delay certifying Pennsylvaniaâs electoral votes despite no evidence that would call those results into question. The election-fraud lie led to the attack on the Capitol.
Nick Troutman, a spokesman for Sen. Gene Yaw (R-Lycoming), the Senate bill’s sponsor, said those concerns ignore the language of the legislation.
âThe legislation only prohibits municipal policies that impose ârequirementsâ on citizens. Since citizens are free to decline voluntary incentives, they are not requirements and are not prohibited by the bill,â Troutman said.
Sturges said the Municipal League offered more specific language to Sen. Yawâs office, but it wasnât included in an amended version of the bill.
Gov. Tom Wolf’s office says the administration opposes the bills as currently written.
Editor's Picks
PARTNERS
FUNDERS
Climate Solutions partners
