1.5 million at risk in PA for crude oil derailment
Alexandra Kanik, PublicSource
In Pennsylvania, nearly 1.5 million people are in potential danger if a train carrying crude oil derails and catches fire, according to a PublicSource analysis.
That is about one in every nine Pennsylvanians, or 11.5 percent of the state’s population.
The analysis also found 327 K-12 schools, 37 hospitals and 61 nursing homes in the state are at risk.
These numbers take on new meaning in the wake of the recent calamitous derailment near Mount Carbon, W. Va. And, a federal report predicts 15 trains carrying crude oil and ethanol in the United States could derail in 2015 alone.
On Feb. 16, the nation watched as blazing orange clouds of fire shot out of crushed tank cars in West Virginia from a derailed CSX train carrying Bakken crude oil. Fires burned for days, drinking water was affected, a house was leveled and hundreds were evacuated from their homes.
The scene had many Pennsylvanians wondering: Will it happen here next?
Fractracker, a group that vets data about fracking, and PennEnvironment, an environmental advocacy group, also published a map looking at crude-oil trains and population. Their numbers vary from ours because we used different methodologies and sources.
PublicSource used the rail lines on which the railroads themselves reported to the state they are moving more than one million gallons of Bakken crude oil at a time. The railroads did not have to report lines where trains carrying less than one million gallons travel. Fractracker used a number based on the number of people who live near lines on which the oil could be moved.
The actual number of people affected in the state may be somewhere in between.
City and emergency response officials across Pennsylvania said they’re concerned about a derailment.
Rick Molchany, director of general services for Lehigh County, said first responders in his county have attended state and national workshops run in conjunction with the railroads.
“We’ve got the training and the determination…but, God, I hope we don’t ever have to respond,” to an oil train fire, he said.
“If something catastrophic happens, there’s no municipality along the railroad that can handle it; the volume is too great,” Pottstown Fire Chief Richard Lengel told the Pottstown Mercury, a PublicSource news partner. “We just have to hope that nothing happens, honestly.”
That was illustrated to an extent in West Virginia when firefighters were forced to let tank car fires burn for days before they were safe enough to extinguish.
In May, federal regulators ordered railroads carrying Bakken crude to give their routes to Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency officials.
The PublicSource analysis shows those at risk within a half-mile on each side of rail lines in the state where trains haul more than one million gallons at a time of Bakken crude oil, which is highly volatile. A half-mile is the federal evacuation zone recommended when a tank car of crude oil catches fire.
There are no state or federal rules requiring that citizens be informed when these trains come through. And the railroads and emergency responders don’t share that information with the public, citing potential terrorism.
What we do know is that about 60 to 70 trains each week carrying crude oil from the Bakken Shale in North Dakota and Montana pass through Pennsylvania on their way to Philadelphia and other East Coast cities with refineries.
Because oil production shot up quickly in the last few years and because no one knows how long the boom will last, it’s unlikely new pipelines will be built soon, so crude oil will likely continue to be moved by rail in large amounts, according to a report from the Congressional Research Service.
The West Virginia derailment, and one in Ontario on Feb. 14, are just the two latest accidents. At least 12 derailments have occurred since early 2013, the most devastating in Lac-Megantic, Quebec, in July 2013, when a runaway train carrying Bakken crude derailed and set off an inferno that killed 47 people.
Since January 2014, Pennsylvania has had at least four derailments involving crude oil. None of them caused any injuries.
The string of derailments has prompted officials, advocacy groups and citizens to call for tougher safety standards, including stronger tank cars, which U.S. regulators haven’t been able to adopt even as more derailments pile up. Regulators and railroads have taken other actions, including slowing trains down in urban areas, and requiring more track inspections and better braking systems.
Local hands tied
Representatives for Norfolk Southern and CSX both said they’ve increased training for first responders in the state.
Regulating railroads is largely left up to the federal government so there’s little local municipalities can do except make sure they’re prepared.
“Our hands are tied,” in terms of regulation, said Michael Huss, Pittsburgh’s deputy director of public safety, on WESA’s Essential Pittsburgh radio show on Feb. 25.
Huss said he’d like to see crude oil trains rerouted around Pittsburgh.
“When you look at Pittsburgh…we don’t have a refinery in the city and therefore I believe that material could be rerouted,” he said.
But rerouting trains around cities isn’t necessarily a good idea, Patricia Reilly, senior vice president of the Association of American Railroads, said on the show. Working with the federal government, railroads weigh many different factors when choosing routes, including population, terrain, class of track and weather conditions, she said.
“Rerouting might sound like a very good solution, but the reality is rerouting those trains might mean moving it to track which is not the best track to move hazardous or flammable liquids,” she said.
Pittsburgh city officials recently completed a risk assessment of crude oil trains coming through the city and the Southwestern Pennsylvania region, but will not release specific information about it to the public because of terrorism concerns.
Fred Millar, a Washington D.C.-based hazardous materials safety advocate, said the security excuse doesn’t hold up.
“Any half-assed terrorist” can see where a good place to blow up a train would be in a major city, he said.
In Philadelphia, activists and local politicians are pushing city emergency management officials to release more information on routes and safety plans for crude oil trains.
“West Virginia’s derailment is a horrifying reminder of what could happen in Philadelphia,” Clean Water Action’s Mary Donahue said in a press release.
‘Too great to ignore’
Although regulating railroads falls under federal jurisdiction, states do have some authority.
Gov. Tom Wolf is reviewing the policies in place for crude oil trains and has met with railroad executives to discuss how to lower the derailment risk, according to a Feb. 27 letter he wrote to President Barack Obama asking for speedier action on improving crude-by-rail safety.
“The potential for disaster is too great to ignore,” Wolf wrote.
The U.S. Department of Transportation has been working on new rail safety rules for more than a year, but the rules are stalled at the White House’s Office of Management and Budget.
Wolf said current standards for tank cars and braking systems are “not sufficient.” He pointed out that newer tank cars built to more stringent standards, CPC-1232s, have still failed in derailments, including the recent one in West Virginia.
He also asked for federal money to hire more rail safety inspectors, saying the state relies on only six inspectors to monitor 5,000 miles of track.
The Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency has focused federal grant dollars on training, said spokesman Cory Angell. And the Department of Environmental Protection is working with emergency responders in areas where crude oil trains travel near major rivers, said spokeswoman Amanda Witman.
“This planning effort was started to specifically address high hazard freight by rail,” Witman said. She added that the effort, which started in June 2014, is not just focused on crude trains, but on trains transporting other hazardous materials.
Bakken crude oil routes in Pennsylvania
About the data
PublicSource relied on the following sources for our Bakken crude-by-rail map: Routes taken by trains carrying more than one million gallons of Bakken crude oil as reported by CSX and Norfolk Southern to the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency; shapefiles of major railroad lines from the Oak Ridge National Laboratory; granular census geographic and population data from the U.S. Census Bureau; data on counties (Census Bureau); a list of Pennsylvania hospitals and nursing homes provided by the Pennsylvania Department of Health and a list of K-12 public and private schools from the Pennsylvania Department of Education.
We began by refining the railroads’ files. In May 2014, federal regulators ordered railroads carrying more than one million gallons of Bakken crude per train to give their routes to the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency. We analyzed those routes and excluded all railroad lines that CSX and Norfolk Southern did not designate as Bakken crude routes.
Once we had refined the rail lines, we were able to create a half-mile buffer zone around them on either side. Merging this buffer zone with Census population data allowed us to identify the number of Pennsylvania citizens living within that evacuation zone.
With our half-mile buffer zone defined, we were able to then add data on hospitals, nursing homes and schools to determine how many fell within the zone.
We collaborated with the CREATE lab at Carnegie Mellon University to make the map interactive. You can zoom in and out to see whether your house, workplace or school is located within the federal half-mile evacuation zone.
PublicSource reporters Eric Holmberg and Halle Stockton helped analyze data for this story.
We’d like to add to this map as more information on crude oil routes in Pennsylvania comes to light. If you have any information on routes these trains take, please contact PublicSource
Sources: Oak Ridge National Laboratory, U.S. Census Bureau, Pennsylvania Department of Health, Pennsylvania Department of Education
Reach Alexandra Kanik at 412.315.0264 or firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow her on Twitter @act_rational.