PA Enviro Groups Issue Report Cards to State Legislators | StateImpact Pennsylvania Skip Navigation

PA Enviro Groups Issue Report Cards to State Legislators

  • Jessica Pupovac/NPR

PennEnvironment

Click on the image above to open an interactive scorecard, released today by a coalition of Pennsylvania environmental advocacy groups.

Pennsylvania’s sweeping new regulations for Marcellus Shale drilling passed with help from both sides of the aisle, environmental groups said today as they unveiled a new tool they hope will inform voters in advance of the November elections.
The “Pennsylvania Marcellus Shale Scorecard” gives a run-down of where each state legislator fell on key provisions of House Bill 1950, or Act 13. The tool was a collaborative effort of four environmental advocacy organizations:PennEnvironment, Conservation Voters of Pennsylvania and local chapters of the Sierra Club and Clean Water Action. It tracks legislators’ votes on several measures in the omnibus legislation and calculates the percentage of those votes the groups deem to be “pro-environment.” While Dems’ scores fall anywhere between zero and 100 percent (or what the environmentalists consider an A+), the highest score for any Republican is a paltry 54 percent.
Although supporters of the new act say that it will improve several statewide environmental provisions, including increasing setbacks from buildings and waterways, during today’s teleconference, the groups called these and other environmental protections “minimal.”
They also lambasted a provision that they said leaves local communities “hamstrung” by preempting local zoning ordinances and relegating authority over the placement of wells, pipelines and other drilling infrastructure to the state.
Industry leaders have applauded the uniform regulations for allowing them to develop natural gas with “certainty.”
Still, controversy over preemption might not be over. Several local politicians have echoed the groups concerns and are exploring legal action in response.
Gov. Tom Corbett signed Act 13 into law Feb. 8. It will take effect on April 16.

Up Next

Environmentalists Critical of EPA's Dimock Results, EPA Releases Sampling Plan