Florida

Putting Education Reform To The Test

Teachers Question Why Proposed Pay Raises Come Before Teacher Evaluations

Sarah Gonzalez / StateImpact Florida

5th grade teacher Beverley Dowell says she hopes the Governor “isn’t trying to buy teacher votes” when he suggested every full-time teacher in the state get a pay raise before their evaluation results come in.

Most districts won’t start identifying, and potentially removing, low-performing teachers from their schools until next year. But Governor Rick Scott said he wants to give every full-time teacher in the state a pay raise now.

“For a while now we’ve been hearing how bad we are,” said Beverley Dowell, a 5th grade teacher at Treasure Island Elementary School in Miami-Dade. “[That] we need to weed out bad teachers, there’s so many bad teachers.”

She says it doesn’t make any sense to give teachers more money before those “bad teachers” have even been identified. 

“On one hand you’re cleaning us out of the system, on the other hand you’re going to reward us with $2,500 because according to the Governor we truly deserve it,” Dowell said. “We have to be concerned.”

Continue Reading

How A C-Rated School Can Be Full of Effective Teachers

The Florida Senate

Florida Senate President Don Gaetz wondered how low-rated schools could be full of teachers earned positive evaluations.

Last month Senate president Don Gaetz raised eyebrows when he questioned the accuracy of Florida’s new teacher evaluations.

The evaluations are based on a complex statistical formula which weighs Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test scores and other factors to calculate how much a teacher influences student learning. The evaluations will eventually contribute to how much a teacher is paid, despite complaints the results have large margins of error and can change significantly from year to year.

“How can you have a C or D ranked school in which 85 percent, or 90 or 95 percent of the teachers are classified as effective or highly effective?” Gaetz told the Associated Press. “It seems to me that those two data points have to have some relationship to each other.”

It’s a question the Tampa Bay Times also looked at on Sunday, asking how Pinellas County schools earning the state’s highest report card grades could have relatively low school-wide teacher evaluation scores?

Continue Reading

State Board of Education Member Resigns Amid Business Troubles

Florida Department of Education

Akshay Desai resigned from the State Board of Education to focus on his struggling health care company.

Gov. Rick Scott filled three slots on the State Board of Education Thursday, reappointing John Padget of Key West and appointing Ada Armas of Coral Gables and John Colon of University Park.

Colon, an executive with Wells Fargo Advisers, replaces Akshay “A.K.” Desai, who resigned from the board. Desai is a major Republican Party fundraiser, but as our friends at Health News Florida report, state regulators say his company, Universal Health Care, overstated assets and submitted “misleading financial statements.”

Desai told the Tampa Bay Times’ Gradebook blog that “he needed to devote 100 percent of his time to ‘current business challenges.'”

Colon’s term ends next year, while Armas and Padget would serve through 2016 with state Senate confirmation.

The newcomers mean Gov. Rick Scott has now appointed a majority of the seven-member board, which also includes Education Commissioner Tony Bennett.

Town Hall: Ask Florida Lawmakers About Their Education Priorities This Session

On Feb. 25, leaders from the Florida Legislature will be answering your questions at a Town Hall on Session 2013, an event sponsored by Global Integrity.

Education is a big part of the conversation. From teacher pay to charter school funding laws, you can ask Florida lawmakers what their education priorities will be during the upcoming legislative session. 

RSVP to join WLRN and The Miami Herald on Monday, Feb. 25th at 6:30pm for the live, free event at the Broward Center for the Performing Arts in Fort Lauderdale.

Guests include:

Read the Florida House of Representatives’ Big Charter School Bill

Terry McCombs / Flickr

A Florida House of Representatives bill would allow charter school to take over empty school district buildings.

Yesterday the House Education Choice and Innovation subcommittee approved a 36-page bill that makes it easier for charter schools to expand.

The bill adds more restrictions to closed charter schools and requires charter schools to post their board, management firm and some spending online.

The bill also requires school districts to turn over empty buildings formerly used for K-12 education to charter schools at no cost. Charter schools must pay for maintenance or reimburse the school district for the cost.

We’ve annotated key sections of the bill below. The bill is a committee bill, and you can track all of the Choice and Innovation subcommittee bills here. You can find all the bills referred to the Education Committee here (choose Education under the “Referred to” dropdown menu).

Continue Reading

House Bill Would Help Charter Schools Expand, But Also Adds More Regulation

myfloridahouse.gov

Rep. George Moraitis, Jr. said the charter school bill he sponsors would fight 'poor performance.'

A House committee has approved a bill which would put rules in place for opening a charter school and warding off troubled charters.

The House Choice and Innovation Subcommittee made a few changes to the bill and more amendments are expected.

“This is not a finished product,” Rep. George Moraitis, Jr., R-Fort Lauderdale, said. “We’re still open to changes as we move forward in the process.”

The bill allows charter schools to use empty school district facilities. Charter schools would have to pay for maintenance, or reimburse the district for maintenance.

The 36-page bill would also prohibit a shuttered charter school from spending more than $10,000 without the prior written permission of the school board or other sponsor, with some exceptions.

Charter school employees would not be allowed to serve on the charter school’s governing board.

Those requirements are a direct result of a case from Orlando.

Continue Reading

Three Questions About College For Lumina Foundation CEO Jamie Merisotis

Lumina Foundation

Lumina Foundation CEO Jamie Merisotis says Florida needs to consider new models for college tuition and student learning.

The Lumina Foundation is committed to enrolling and graduating more students from college. CEO Jamie Merisotis takes that message around the country.

Last week, he spoke to the Economic Club of Florida.

The foundation’s goal is for 60 percent of Americans to earn a high-quality post secondary credential or degree by 2025. Merisotis took questions from the audience.

Q: Does the Lumina Foundation have a position on how the university systems should price their services? In my day, the university system priced its tuition on a quarterly basis, so we took all the hours we could take per quarter. We all finished in four years flat. What do you say about that – do we need to go back?

A: You bet. There are two sides to this financing equation – two elements that you’ve got to address when you’re dealing with the issues of redesigning the financing system.

One side is the cost side, which is getting more productivity out of the enterprise. What I mean is literally increasing the capacity of the system to serve more people better.

Continue Reading

Explaining Digital Learning Day

trudeau / Flickr

Today is Digital Learning Day, an effort to raise awareness about the benefits of integrating more technology into education.

Today is Digital Learning Day, part of an effort to put more emphasis on the possibilities computers, the Internet and new technology offer to improve education.

Advocates argue access and customization are the biggest advantages to digital instruction. Students often find digital instruction more engaging — pull out those smart phones and Wi-Fi enabled iPods, students — and the materials can be more interactive and easily updated.

Critics argue there’s often no evidence that digital instruction is more effective, and school districts may be wasting money on ineffective, shiny gizmos. Education business analyst Lee Wilson argues digital textbooks on the iPad can cost more than five times as much as a traditional textbook and require additional management and training for effective use.

But Florida lawmakers believe in the advantages of digital learning and have required schools to deliver half of their instruction digitally beginning in the fall of 2015. The state requires students to take one online course in order to graduate high school. Florida students are also more likely to take a standardized test on a computer than in other states.

Continue Reading

CEO Sees Educational Progress In Florida; Says It’s Too Slow

Lumina Foundation

Lumina Foundation president and CEO Jamie Merisotis. He says the number of Floridians earning higher education degrees is not keeping pace with job openings.

The percentage of Floridians earning college degrees is not increasing fast enough to keep pace with the job market, according to the head of a foundation working to boost higher education graduates.

That’s what Jamie Merisotis, president and CEO of the Lumina Foundation, told the Economic Club of Florida last week.

“It’s an urgent need,” Merisotis said and nearly every state is far from that goal.

“Here in Florida, according to the most recent data, 37 percent of the state’s working age residents (ages 25 to 64) have at least a two-year college degree,” Merisotis said. “That figure is virtually unchanged over the course of the last four years.”

That means the rates are flat in Florida, and “when it comes to educational progress, flat is actually frightening. That’s because educational success is increasingly linked to economic prosperity.”

Lumina’s strategic plan, Goal 2025, is to have 60 percent of Americans holding a high quality post secondary degree, certificate or other credential by 2025.

The Lumina Foundation is a donor to Florida C.A.N., which supports StateImpact Florida.

Continue Reading

Michelle Rhee Visits The Daily Show

 

Michelle Rhee, the education firebrand/lightning rod who is the former chancellor of Washington, D.C. public schools, sat down for an interview with Jon Stewart on The Daily Show last night.

Rhee founded education advocacy group StudentsFirst. Rhee has advised Florida Gov. Rick Scott. She is known for vociferously challenging teacher’s unions and promoting policies

Stewart particularly questioned Rhee about her treatment of teachers and the effect on professional morale.  Stewart also asked if it was fair to minimize the effect of poverty and upbringing on student achievement, as Rhee’s brand of “no excuses” school policies often do.

The wave of new education policies, Stewart said, have left teachers feeling like a football team forced to adjust each time a new offensive is brought in.

Florida recently earned a B- on a StudentsFirst report card grading state education policy, the second-highest grade in the nation. StudentsFirst has an active Florida chapter and worked unsuccessfully last year on behalf of the so-called “parent trigger” law.

Stewart gave Rhee the extended interview treatment, broadcasting a portion of the sit down and then posting the full interrogation online.

Continue Reading

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Economy
Education