Putting Education Reform To The Test


What Role Will Unions Play in Reform?


Florida’s teacher unions have played a central role in the debate about how best to improve schools.

The Florida Education Association has organized political opposition to Gov. Rick Scott’s proposed budget cuts in the spring of 2011. The group also fought bills, which later became law, stripping teacher tenure and requiring public employees take a three percent pay cut to fund pensions.

The group is now challenging the pay cuts in court.

Scott has said he opposed collective bargaining for teachers and supporters hope to target unions next year. Stripping those rights has been an issue in Wisconsin, Ohio and elsewhere.

Florida teachers have a protection other states do not enjoy — a constitutional right to unionize. Stripping collective bargaining rights would require a three-fifths majority of both legislators and voters in order to amend the state constitution.

But unions are also essential to efforts intended to improve Florida schools.

State law requires school districts design systems to evaluate teachers and pay bonuses to the highest-rated teachers. Unions in Hillsborough and Miami-Dade counties have been central in building support for merit pay among teachers critical of the concept.

Researchers have concluded teacher support for merit pay programs are critical for those programs to improve student performance.


Latest Posts

As Florida Reduces Testing, Teacher Evaluation Questions Remain

Florida lawmakers’ decision to end mandatory final exams for every class will mean that more teachers’ performance will be judged on subjects they don’t teach. Concerned about the amount of testing in schools — and pressured by activists and educators — this year lawmakers rescinded a state law that requires school districts to have a […]

Florida Teachers Consider ‘Civil Disobedience’ To Say No To Testing

In September, Alachua County kindergarten teacher Susan Bowles refused to give a state reading test. She told the parents of her students it was an act of civil disobedience. The Florida Department of Education later suspended the exam for this year. Florida requires that most students are tested every year. Those results help determine which […]

Broward Schools Want Changes To Evaluations And High School Schedules

Broward County school and union leaders want to make changes to test-based teacher evaluations and the county’s high school schedule. Superintendent Robert Runcie announced two task forces will study the issues and recommend changes. One goal is to come up with a teacher evaluation system that is less about punishing teachers who earn low scores […]

New Teacher’s Union Leader Promises More Florida Activism

At a Spanish restaurant in Miami’s Wynwood neighborhood, one of the most powerful women in education, Lily Eskelsen Garcia, pumps up union members by telling them where her career started – the cafeteria. Lily Eskelsen Garcia is the first Latina elected to lead the nation’s largest union – the National Education Association. Thursday was her […]

Teacher’s Union President Wants New Direction For Common Standards

The head of the nation’s largest teacher’s union says school districts are botching the implementation of shared math and language arts standards known as Common Core. National Education Association president Dennis Van Roekel said he still supports the standards in an open letter posted on the union’s website, Education Week has more: “Seven of ten […]

The Back-To-School Economy: StateImpact Florida On The Sunshine Economy

A new school year is underway for children across Florida. A new year brings with it the potential of new learning, new skills, and new challenges. Are our kids learning what they need to in order to compete in the global job market of the future? WLRN’s Sunshine Economy looked at the education industry with […]

UM Students Protest Firing Of Miss Betty

Students at the University of Miami (UM) are protesting the firing of a popular cafeteria worker. Betty Asbury was fired two weeks ago by the food service company Chartwells. According to Asbury, she was fired after a man walked by her cashier post without paying for breakfast. Asbury says her district manager reviewed security video and […]

Five Questions For The National Education Association VP

The first presidential debate of 2012 will be held tomorrow night between President Barack Obama and Gov. Mitt Romney. The National Education Association will be watching. NEA Vice President Lily Eskelsen says the differences between the two candidates “are night and day.” The NEA has already endorsed Obama, and Eskelsen was appointed by Obama to […]

Chicago Teacher’s Strike Settlement A Victory For Actual Merit Pay, Researcher Argues

Education researcher Jay P. Greene argues the agreement between the school system and the Chicago Teacher’s Union is a victory for true merit pay over “phony merit pay.” What’s the difference? From Greene’s blog: True merit pay — the kind of compensation for job performance found in most industries — provides effective employees with continued […]

How Florida School Districts Are Negotiating Next Year’s Teacher Contracts

Contract negotiations between Florida’s school districts and teacher unions is in full swing, but district face very different budget situations. Here’s a roundup of labor news around the state from the past week: Palm Beach County is facing a $31.7 million budget shortfall, but the teachers’ union is asking for raises, according to the South […]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »