Pennsylvania

Energy. Environment. Economy.

Earth First Shuts Down Drilling Site in Moshannon State Forest

Update 9:30 pm:

A blockade against natural gas drilling at a well site in Moshannon State Forest that began Sunday morning has been dismantled by police, according to protestors. Witnesses say police used a cherry picker to remove two tree-sitters this evening at about 8:30 pm.

Alex Lotorto, a protester who joined a rally at the end of the access road, said nobody was hurt during the incident. There are unconfirmed reports that three people were arrested.

screen shot, Earth First!

This photo appeared on the Earth First! website soon after the protest began early Sunday morning in Moshannon State Forest.

A group calling itself Marcellus Earth First! set up a blockade in Moshannon State Forest, preventing the natural gas company EQT from operating a well. A report on an Earth First!  website says the blockade on a gravel road began before 9:30 Sunday morning with about 40 protestors who successfully prevented a truck from entering the drill site.

EQT spokesperson Natalie Cox says the drilling operations have shut down over safety concerns for the company’s employees, contractors, police and protesters. Cox says activities at the well pad were in the early stages.

EQT is one of the largest drillers in Pennsylvania, with about 300 active wells in the western part of the state. For more information on EQT’s drilling operations, visit our Shale Map App.

Pike County resident Alex Lotorto, who says he’s not a member of Marcellus Earth First!, but joined the rally, says two people have climbed trees and strung cables across an access road in such a way that cutting them would cause the tree climbers to fall and face serious injury or even death. Lotorto says state police are on the scene.

“Police interaction has been courteous and respectful,” says Lotorto.  ”We want to make this safe as possible.”

A state police officer reached by phone at the Dubois, Pa. office would not provide any information. The Moshannon State Forest spans three counties, but the protest is in the Clearfield County section of the forest.

Lotoro said a group of protestors had dragged logs and branches from the forest to build blockades across the access road the night before the protest. A sign hanging from the site reads “Marcellus Earth First, no fracking no compromise.” Earth First! is an environmental activist group that uses direct action and is primarily known for protesting logging in forests along the West Coast. The group often employs the tactic of climbing into trees to stop industrial activity and call attention to their cause.

Janis Copenhaver lives near Big Run, Jefferson County, not too far from the drill site. Reached by phone, Copenhaver said she didn’t know anything about the action until she overheard others in her town talking about it.

“I wish I had the time and gumption to do this,” said Copenhaver. “But I have to have a fulltime job, pay a mortgage, and take care of my animals. I appreciate it when someone else is trying to defend the earth and the life I love living.”

Copenhaver said it took her two hours to find the protesters on a remote access road in the forest. She says she plans to bring food and water up the mountain.

“I can’t be up there hanging from a tree,” said Copenhaver, “but I’ll do what I can.”

Copenhaver says she worries about gas drilling’s impact on her water. She says another drill rig sits about 600 yards from her drinking water well and she gets her water tested every two weeks. Lately, she says the salinity, and the amount of total dissolved solids have increased.

“It’s just too frightening, so I started buying bottled water yesterday,” said Copenhaver.

Drilling for natural gas in state forests is controversial. Although the state has leased out mineral rights in state forests since 1947, the Marcellus Shale boom has meant a rapid expansion of industrial activity on state land. More than 700,000 acres of for­est land have already been leased – about twenty per­cent of that for Mar­cel­lus pads. The Department of Conservation and Natural Resources pre­dicts more than 1,000 drilling rigs may dot the forests, once pro­duc­tion is at full capac­ity. Many feared Gov. Corbett would expand drilling in the forests, but his 2012-2013 budget did not include any plans to lease out additional state forest land for natural gas drilling.

Comments

  • Protecting Our Waters

    EQT is leaking toxic flowback in Tioga, as well as fracking our forests. With every incident there is more support for the blockaders. The response I’m hearing from folks is: “Wish I was there.”
         Protecting Our Waters reported on this blockade here: 
    http://protectingourwaters.wordpress.com/2012/07/08/blockaders-stop-eqt-fracking-operation-protect-moshannon-state-forest/ That is terrible about Copenhaver’s water turning more saline and murky– I’m glad to hear that she is buying bottled water to protect herself but it’s horrifying to keep hearing more of these cases every day. Just heard of another one in Bradford County, an 80 year old man who has to haul water up his hill in one-gallon jugs just to drink safe water after gas drillers contaminated his water, which had been excellent quality for 80 years. Time to stand up for the underdogs! 

    • http://twitter.com/knappAP Mike Knapp

       If folks are having issues with their water, they need to report it to DEP immediately so that they can properly investigate it, and direct the gas company to deliver water in the interim. 

      • The_White_Rabbit

        You mean like Dimock? When USEPA had to come in and do the state’s job due to bureaucrats in Harrisburg?

        • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

          The USEPA says the water is safe after numerous testing in Democ, Pa. 

          • The_White_Rabbit

            It is “Dimock” and don’t believe the final USEPA report has been released unless you have some insider information?

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

            Final report? The saga will continue and go on and on I doubt if a final report will ever develop. Just think of all those that are in the EPA that look at it as job security. 

          • The_White_Rabbit

            I take your response as you are not aware of any final determinations? Yet you said USEPA found not problems!

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

            Latest I heard a few weeks ago EPA testing was Just fine if you have a update link it . By the way thanks for seeing the typo. Bunny at least this guy is trying to possibly find the real culprit when it comes to water. Just have a open mind here because it could be useful to everyone even those not even close to drilling. See 
            http://gomarcellusshale.com/forum/topics/private-well-owners-in-pennsylvania-please-read-this-will-benefit give it some consideration. 

          • The_White_Rabbit

            As far as I am aware there is no USEPA final report yet! However, if you know of any let us know.

          • Mike Knapp

            There is absolutely no disputing the fact that the PA DEP came down swiftly and very hard on the company involved in the Dimock saga. They ordered the company to deliver water for 3 years. They fined them, they ordered them to pay each affected landowner twice the value of their home ( over 4 million dollars), and most painfully they ordered them to plug several wells, which will cost them many millions more. They were very vocal and very critical. DEP has also shut down several other drillers after incidents. To characterize them they way you are is
            extremely unfair and inaccurate.

          • The_White_Rabbit

            The reply box is getting a bit skinny. Mike don’t take this personally but you seem (from your posts) as a paid pro gas whore.

            PADEP normally characterizes environmental problems. Then does not put specific time limits on a pollution incident but requires treatment and testing to insure safe drinking water. Not only this but feasible abatment of the contaminated groundwater is a normal function of a PADEP action. Requiring payment has nothing to do with protecting the environment (note what the PADEP acronomy stands for. Although consiedering some of the former PADEP leaders now whoring for truthland not surprised on the Harrisburg management of this case..

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Victoria-Switzer/1846778906 Victoria Switzer

        water truck still delivers water to folks around Dimock…it is just part of the process, part of their operations. I suppose some think it is a fair trade, I just wish the gas company had been honest and explained the risks to the folks who trusted them in 2005-2006 and when they made a mistake-drilling, casing etc. they admitted it instead of putting the landowner on trial. If the gas company had been good neighbors in the beginning things would not be so bad for some of us now….the numbers are growing and the silent are starting to speak-even large landowners are starting to speak out.

  • Dave

    They have my total support. I’ve had a couple wells by my house and everyday I worry that they’re going to break through the rock and contaminate the aquifer.
    I’m also worried about all the illegal dumping going on and how that is going to affect the water once it starts entering the water supplies.

    I’d rather meet the challenges of dwindling global energy supplies with clean water! 

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

      Where is the illegal dumping taking place? Please do your civic duty and report it to your local police to investigate. 

  • Nofracking

    We wouldn’t need to drill for this if we weren’t funneling it to the military for their war crimes

    U.S. Military Energy Consumption- facts and figures
    http://www.energybulletin.net/node/29925

    • http://twitter.com/knappAP Mike Knapp

      And we won’t have to fight wars for energy if we are allowed to develop our own resources!

      • The_White_Rabbit

        No Mike. We will just have to fight wars over clean water as some predict if the state doesn’t start doing their job in Harrisburg.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

      God Bless our Military it is to bad there are others that say their god orders them to kill us. If it were not for this perhaps there could be some peace! 

  • Mildred Johnson

    I wondered my water had a dirty color and the faucet spit water instead of a steady flow.

    Is this as a result of this drilling?

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

      May be your well casing has deteriorated and rusted through. Sense Pa is the only  state besides Alaska that allows a private water well to be drilled or dug with no regulation, a water well can be bad to start with!

    • The_White_Rabbit

      Well owners should test their wells regularily and typically annually. There are other sources of groundwater problems aside from gas drilling. Suggest going to local lab and asking about their typical analysis. Possibly consider coliform (sewage indicator), basic toxic metals (lead, chromium, etc.), and possibly limited organics. Possibly deteriorated well (also make sure well cap is sealed adequately) and land use can have an effect.

  • Mary Carol

    Let’s get rid of Republicans that vote against the environment, against health care and use our taxes to subsidize the oil and gas industry.  While we can still vote, we must dismantle the Voter ID Bill.  If our representatives in Harrisburg and Washington, DC,  vote against our water, against our health and against our right to vote, let’s get rid of these bums in November. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

      Hey I need a ID to cash a check , start a banking account, even get a drivers license. A ID to prove who your are to insure one vote for one person is  not oppression but rather protection of those who vote as a civic duty. 
      Lets vote out the democrats that believe giving a blank check to BIG PHARMA and the medical industry at the tax payers expense is a good idea. I wont even mention Solyndra! 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

     TDS total dissolved solids that are elevated do not mean water is bad!  Water with a extremely low TDS  is not healthy and could even lead to death as it lacks minerals that are in the water in natural form that the body needs.
      I once tested the water that supplied the River Rouge power plant in Detroit Michigan in order to  set a base line for a water deionization trailer unit, The City of Detroit was supplying to the plant regular city water same as residential and the TDS was a bit over 500PPM TDS I was at the gard shack and said hey this should be interesting  and took a sample of HIGH PRICED  5 gallon bottled cooler water it tested out at over 700 PPM TDS. 
      TDS can change due to fluctuations in a water supply drought conditions, even the settling of water over a period of time can change the TDS. .
     As to Pike County res­i­dent Alex Lotorto, who says he’s not a mem­ber of Mar­cel­lus Earth First!, but joined the rally,  really?  You might like to see who this guy really is see http://eidmarcellus.org/marcellus-shale/alex-lotorto-occupy-guy/6706/

    • The_White_Rabbit

      Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) is good as an indicator of potential water quality issues but does NOT reflect what (typically) inorganics are the reason for a relative high TDS. The only way to tell if there is contamination is to study the specific area background and compare the specific inorganics (not just the TDS) and possibly organics. This is where the PADEP has failed in not allowing fied staff to “characterize” a possible problem (including determine site background) and define a logical abatement for prooblems. This is not limited to insuring there is clean drinking water and continued testing, but an abatement feasible for contaminated enviromental media. Bottom line? Do it right the first time.

      EID seems to just do personal attacks on activists rather than the argument. That logic (or lack) off will eventually come back to bite you on your collective butt.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000972696707 Billy Whyde

        The idea of a study is a great idea, but if done might be horrifying simply due to the fact that water well construction in Pa might well be the cause to begin with! 
        See  where private land owners require no license  http://www.dcnr.state.pa.us/topogeo/groundwater/Act610.aspx In part:
        (b) The provisions of this section shall not be applicable to-(1) Any farmer performing any function on any land owned or leased by him for farming purposes.(2) Any natural person drilling a well on land owned by him or of which he is a lessee and used by him as his residence.http://www.dcnr.state.pa.us/topogeo/groundwater/water_well_faq.aspx Who must be licensed to drill a water well in Pennsylvania? 
        Any person who intends to construct a water well in the Commonwealth must first secure a Water-Well Driller’s License and a Drilling Rig Permit, unless it is on land owned or leased by the person drilling the well for farming or is his/her residence. Does using a licensed driller insure my well will be properly constructed? 
        Unfortunately it does not. Drillers are NOT required to demonstrate knowledge of proper drilling or well construction practices in order to become licensed. Pennsylvania has developed construction standardsonly for public water-supply wells. There are no statewide construction standards for domestic supply wells. Visit the DEP web page on private wells for more information. Also, check with your township or county government for applicable local ordinances.   With that being said how in the H can anyone be pointing a finger? 

  • The_White_Rabbit

    Contamination problems are addressed and characterized every day by PADEP. There should be no difference for gas drillers. Superfund (CERCLA), RCRA, fuel spills, and assorted contamination are typical PADEP issues with common residential and commercial water wells. It is hard to point fingers when characterization was non existent like at Dimock.

  • Hawley08

    You people r nuts. They have been drilling holes in the ground for years. How do u heat ur homes? Ur messing with families who feed there children with this thing called a JOB. You all should try one.

    • The_White_Rabbit

      Oil drilling in Pennsylvania goes back to the Drake well around 150 years ago. However that is not the same as going 8,000 plus feet and hydraulically fracking. By your logic we should never protest anything if we use a company’ s product. Again, do it right and correct problems.

      • Hawley08

        Water is used to frack. What is water doing to the ground. If its hurting us u better call god.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brian-Oram/1503951853 Brian Oram

    Pennsylvania Private Well Survey Watershed Monitoring Marcellus Shale Issues Sourcewater Protection – Working Together to Make a Positive Change – Check Out
    http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/NMG6RQ3

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brian-Oram/1503951853 Brian Oram

    A fact based review of Dimock, PA – Well by Well
    http://www.water-research.net/dimockwellwater.htm

  • Upstate Girl

    Need to bounce that guy out of office the long term effects of fracking is going to turn the once beautiful state of PA into a toxic wasteland.We thought we would retire in PA not even a blip on the radar at this point. There is still time to save your state.

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Education