Florida

Putting Education Reform To The Test

Analyzing Florida’s Class Size Limit Penalties

Sarah Gonzalez / StateImpact Florida

Florida lawmakers may change the rules for calculating class size limits, which could give district schools more flexibility.

Florida lawmakers are considering a bill which would change the way the state calculates class size limits required by the state constitution.

Lawmakers may allow district schools to use the more flexible rules granted to charter schools.

District schools must calculate the class size of every classroom and count every violation. Charter schools are allowed to use a school-wide average, which school officials say is more forgiving.

In the 2010-2011 school year, 28 of 71 Florida schools districts – 39 percent — were penalized for not meeting class size limits, according to state data. In 2011-2012, 22 of 71 Florida districts — 31 percent — did not meet class size limits.

By contrast, six of 457 charter schools did not meet class size limits in the 2010-2011 school year — 1.3 percent. In the 2011-2012 school year 15 of 517 charter schools did not meet the limits — 2.9 percent.

Schools which do not abide by the limits suffer a financial penalty — losing half their share of a state funding source for every student above the class size limit.

Those penalties can add up: Broward County schools have lost $9.4 million in funding over the past two years for class size violations, according to state data. Palm Beach and Miami-Dade schools were penalized more than $2 million each over the past two years, while Duval County schools lost more than $1 million.

That money is transferred to schools which abide by class size limits.

Hillsborough County school, for instance, have received an additional $2.3 million over the past two years at the expense of Broward schools and others. Orange County schools received $2.1 million while Pinellas and Polk County schools received more than $1 million each.

The Florida Department of Education has more details about how class size is calculated on their website.

Show rows.
District
2011-2012 Adjustment
2010-2011 Adjustment
2-Year Total
Alachua-$57,467-$37,641-$95,108
Baker$33,486$28,366$61,852
Bay$155,782$130,663$286,445
Bradford$21,942$17,937$39,879
Brevard$466,726$386,252$852,978
Broward-$8,620,821-$732,194-$9,353,015
Calhoun$14,664-$2,989$11,675
Charlotte$108,664$92,040$200,704
Citrus$102,515$86,751$189,266
Clay$242,404$204,355$446,759
Collier$286,657-$715,584-$428,927
Columbia-$79,048-$22,236-$101,284
Miami-Dade-$576,650-$1,657,374-$2,234,024
DeSoto$31,102$26,431$57,533
Dixie-$3,781-$15,447-$19,228
Duval-$647,240-$362,942-$1,010,182
Escambia$261,936$220,937$482,873
Flagler$79,826$65,885$145,711
Franklin-$297$5,379$5,082
Gadsden-$1,960$31,697$29,737
Gilchrist$17,333-$21,216-$3,883
Glades$8,428-$4,759$3,669
Gulf$12,949$11,182$24,131
Hamilton-$43,259-$15,286-$58,545
Hardee$34,808$29,254$64,062
Hendry$46,414-$6,384$40,030
Hernando$152,234$128,773$281,007
Highlands$81,473$69,076$150,549
Hillsborough$1,265,703$1,061,079$2,326,782
Holmes-$10,403-$8,928-$19,331
Indian River$107,504$89,825$197,329
Jackson$45,623$38,929$84,552
Jefferson-$1,209-$2,833-$4,042
Lafayette-$6,122-$21,432-$27,554
Lake$243,969$205,321$449,290
Lee$486,635$401,863$888,498
Leon$216,418-$1,568$214,850
Levy-$60,346-$10,960-$71,306
Liberty-$672-$2,205-$2,877
Madison$16,763$14,276$31,039
Manatee-$180,280-$64,448-$244,728
Marion$280,036$232,667$512,703
Martin$120,881$99,767$220,648
Monroe$48,798$41,834$90,632
Nassau$75,887$63,554$139,441
Okaloosa$187,499$152,799$340,298
Okeechobee$43,530$37,566$81,096
Orange$1,174,904$961,289$2,136,193
Osceola$329,434$270,636$600,070
Palm Beach$1,123,693-$3,952,562-$2,828,869
Pasco-$516,348$365,710-$150,638
Pinellas$667,243$571,438$1,238,681
Polk$568,459$472,742$1,041,201
Putnam-$14,609-$4,628-$19,237
St. Johns$210,835$171,627$382,462
St. Lucie$250,232$209,123$459,355
Santa Rosa-$2,499-$24,810-$27,309
Sarasota$245,995-$114,974$131,021
Seminole$428,920$361,449$790,369
Sumter$36,393$30,575$66,968
Suwannee-$26,234-$8,060-$34,294
Taylor$18,656-$1,225$17,431
Union-$813-$7,648-$8,461
Volusia$402,908$341,955$744,863
Wakulla$33,591$28,588$62,179
Walton$49,228$40,367$89,595
Washington-$526$19,764$19,238
FAMU Lab School-$1,282-$3,424-$4,706
FAU-Palm Beach$4,884-$2,524$2,360
UF Lab$7,902$6,560$14,462
Total$0$0$0

Comments

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Economy
Education