Putting Education Reform To The Test


What Role Will Unions Play in Reform?


Florida’s teacher unions have played a central role in the debate about how best to improve schools.

The Florida Education Association has organized political opposition to Gov. Rick Scott’s proposed budget cuts in the spring of 2011. The group also fought bills, which later became law, stripping teacher tenure and requiring public employees take a three percent pay cut to fund pensions.

The group is now challenging the pay cuts in court.

Scott has said he opposed collective bargaining for teachers and supporters hope to target unions next year. Stripping those rights has been an issue in Wisconsin, Ohio and elsewhere.

Florida teachers have a protection other states do not enjoy — a constitutional right to unionize. Stripping collective bargaining rights would require a three-fifths majority of both legislators and voters in order to amend the state constitution.

But unions are also essential to efforts intended to improve Florida schools.

State law requires school districts design systems to evaluate teachers and pay bonuses to the highest-rated teachers. Unions in Hillsborough and Miami-Dade counties have been central in building support for merit pay among teachers critical of the concept.

Researchers have concluded teacher support for merit pay programs are critical for those programs to improve student performance.


Latest Posts

Feedback Loop: What’s on Your Mind About Academy of Arts and Minds

Sarah Gonzalez‘ story Wednesday about the business deals of a Miami-area charter school drew strong reader responses. Intelligentmom came to the school’s defense, arguing students were left without books due to surprising enrollment growth. Academy of Arts and Minds students are prospering: The Academy of Arts & Minds is an A+ school with a 98 […]

Teachers Join Wall Street Protests Online

Teachers are joining the anti-corporate Occupy Wall Street movement that has been spreading across the country since mid-September. The Occupy Education blog features photos of teachers holding up messages outlining how they work on behalf of their students. Many of the messages imply that administrators or bureaucrats undermine their efforts. “I see my students as […]

Organizing Parent ‘Unions’

Parents unhappy with their children’s schools are using labor union tactics to build support for charter schools, according to a story by the Associated Press. California was the first state to adopt a so-called ‘parent trigger’ law, which allows a majority of parents to vote to convert a district school to a charter school. Florida […]

A StateImpact Florida Series: Do Charter Schools Work?

For 15 years Florida has conducted an experiment in public education. The goal was to improve the entire education system by granting charter schools more leeway to innovate. Welcome to StateImpact Florida’s Charter Schools 101 series examining the effect those schools have had on students, teachers, parents and communities — and what comes next. One […]

Florida Teachers’ Union Take Reform Law to Court

Florida’s teacher union will challenge a law ending long-term contracts and requiring merit pay in court, according to the Associated Press. The law, known as the Student Success Act or S. 736, was passed this spring. School districts are just starting to design systems to evaluate teachers and pay the highest-rated teachers more. For more […]

Teachers Believe Income Is Out of Their Hands

First grade teacher Elton Wright feels powerless. He and his wife, also a teacher, are absorbing a 3 percent cut in pay required earlier this year by the Florida Legislature. “People are angry,” said Wright, who teaches at Eagle’s Nest Elementary School in Orange County. “They feel as though this was forced on them. There […]

Five Things To Know About Florida’s New Education Requirements

The new teacher evaluations and merit pay plans school districts are rolling out this year that StateImpact Florida reported yesterday are just a portion of a broad education reform package lawmakers approved last spring. Here’s what to know about the Student Success Act, also known as Senate bill 736:

Merit Pay Could Mean Big Rewards for Florida Teachers

The best Miami-Dade teachers could buy a new car with their bonuses this year while most of their colleagues may only be able to replace an alternator with their bonuses. The difference in the size of those checks is an attempt to pay teachers based on their performance and that of their students, also known […]

Groups Running Up No Child Left Behind Lobbying Tab

Education groups have spent $47 million lobbying the federal government through the first half of 2011, according to Center for Responsive Politics research, as Congress and the federal education department try to decide how to deal with the long-overdue reauthorization of No Child Left Behind. The group reports that $3 million more was spent on […]

Five Ways Teachers Are Changing

The National Center for Education Information released its most recent national teacher survey this morning and it shows some changes among the country’s 3.2 million educators. Teachers are “slightly more satisfied” with their working conditions and community status than they were in 2005, 1996, 1990 and 1986 surveys. About 40 percent of teachers hired since […]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »