Florida

Putting Education Reform To The Test

Topics

How Florida Teachers Are Evaluated, Paid

Background

Fifty percent of a teacher’s evaluation is based on a formula called the Value Added Model. It predicts how students should score on the state’s standardized exam – the FCAT, and rates teachers based on how well their students measured up to the predicted FCAT score.

The other 50 percent of a teacher’s evaluation comes from principal observations by school principals.

By 2014, teachers evaluation will determine how much teachers get paid and whether they keep their jobs.

The first bill Gov. Rick Scott signed into law, SB 736 rewrote how teachers are paid and retained across the state.

Here’s what has changed:

  1. Rating teacher performance. The law requires districts to rate teachers and administrators annually, according to a legislative analysis, with half of their score based on student Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test Performance over a three-year period.Read more »
  2. How teachers are paid. New hires will no longer have to climb the decades-long seniority ladder to earn the highest salaries. Now, the highest-rated teachers can earn the top salaries just a few years out of college. Highly-rated teachers already working can opt out of the merit pay system — but if they switch districts they would be paid on their performance, according to a United Teachers of Dade Q & A. Teachers will also no longer be guaranteed additional pay for advanced degrees.
  3. Job security. New hires will no longer enjoy long-term contracts, but instead must be rehired on an annual basis. Those already teaching are again exempted from the new law, but teachers who switch districts would then move to annual contracts.
  4. Political motivations. Lawmakers approved the law, in part, to reinforce a $700 million federal Race To The Top grant, according to the legislative analysis. Districts will use half that grant to design, implement and fund the first three years of their performance pay systems.
  5. The goal. Reformers believe boosting pay will draw better quality teachers to the field, and that better teachers will produce better student results.

Latest Posts

Feedback Loop: Debating Whether Principals Are Issuing Snap Judgments

Is 20 minutes enough time to figure out how well a teacher is doing his or her job? That’s what Miami-Dade teacher Karla Mats asked after she received a 20-minute observation from her principal — the minimum time required by the district. Mats was disappointed she was not among the highest-rated teachers and she questioned […]

How 20 Minutes With A Principal Determines 12 Months Of Teacher Pay

When Florida teachers were evaluated last year, the stakes for most of them were pretty low. No more. Soon, teacher evaluations will be tied to teacher pay. Starting this year, half of a teacher’s evaluation is based on a classroom observation by the school principal. (The other half is based on a formula that predicts how students should […]

Tennessee Study Identifies Shortcomings In Teacher Evaluations

A report on Tennessee teacher evaluations could have big implications in Florida as well. The report found Tennessee schools “systematically failed” to identify low-performing teachers through a combination of student test score improvement and principal evaluations, according to The Tennessean. Often, a principal’s evaluation and the teacher’s student testing score did not match. Three-quarters of […]

Challenge To Teacher Merit Pay Rule Underway In Tallahassee

A judge in Tallahassee is hearing a legal challenge to a state rule regarding teacher evaluations and merit pay. The Florida Legislature passed Senate Bill 736 last year, known as the “Student Success Act.” It sets standards for teacher evaluations and pay based on performance. Once the law went into effect last summer, state education […]

After Further Review, UMass Education Students Object To New Evaluation

Teachers-in-training at the University of Massachusetts are leading a protest against a pilot national teacher evaluation program being developed by testing giant Pearson and Stanford University, the New York Times reports. The students and their instructor are worried that turning over two 10-minute videos and a 40-page test to a faceless evaluator will not produce […]

Inside FCAT 2.0: What Changes Mean for Teachers, Students

Danna Contreras doesn’t like the new FCAT. The sophomore at Booker T. Washington High School in Miami emigrated from Colombia three years ago. She wears thick, pink-rimmed glasses and she squints a lot. She says the new computerized version is harder to take. “I think I am better with paper, not on the computer because […]

Some Teachers’ Unions Changing Their Approach To School Reform

The Washington Post published a story looking at the Montgomery County teachers’ union, and how union leadership has worked with the school district on training teachers, firing low-performing teacher and setting budget priorities. The cooperation is one reason the suburban D.C. district is one of the nation’s best public school systems, according to some quoted […]

Socrates “Needs Improvement”

What’s Socrates’ value-added score, and would he be able to keep his job? Probably not, according to a humorous post at a ASCD, the nation’s largest curriculum organization. Here’s the clever finish: The results were posted in the Agora for all to see  the quality and performance of their teacher.   Socrates failed.    He simply spent […]

South Florida School Tests FCAT Placebo

A South Florida school is feeding students “FCAT power bars” and hoping the apple-flavored cereal bar gives students more confidence facing the annual Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test, according to the Sun-Sentinel. The district says they don’t want kids at Palm Beach County’s Hagen Road Elementary School to take the test on an empty stomach. But […]

Feedback Loop: Bill Gates And Florida’s Teacher Evaluations

Last week’s story on Florida’s teacher evaluation formula drew some thoughtful responses, including a deeper at the issues look over on the Shanker Blog. Many of the comments here expressed disbelief that Florida’s formula could measure what was promised. Floridagadfly says teaching can not be boiled down to a statistical model because students are not […]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Economy
Education