Putting Education Reform To The Test


SB 736 - The Student Success Act Outlines How Florida Teachers Get Paid


The first bill Gov. Rick Scott signed into law, SB 736 rewrote how teachers are paid and retained across the state.

The Florida Education Association has filed a lawsuit challenging the law, arguing the law unconstitutionally strips teachers or their ability to negotiate pay.

The bill makes a number of sweeping, statewide changes including:

  1. Rating teacher performance. The law requires districts to rate teachers and administrators annually, according to a legislative analysis, with half of their score based on student Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test Performance over a three-year period.
    Districts can negotiate the remaining half of the rating with teachers, but it should be based on instructional practice or leadership. For non-FCAT classes, such as physical education or art, districts have until 2014–2015 to develop and implement tests.
  2. How teachers are paid. New hires will no longer have to climb the decades-long seniority ladder to earn the highest salaries. Now, the highest-rated teachers can earn the top salaries just a few years out of college. Highly-rated teachers already working can opt out of the merit pay system — but if they switch districts they would be paid on their performance, according to a United Teachers of Dade Q & A. Teachers will also no longer be guaranteed additional pay for advanced degrees.
  3. Job security. New hires will no longer enjoy long-term contracts, but instead must be rehired on an annual basis. Those already teaching are again exempted from the new law, but teachers who switch districts would then move to annual contracts.
  4. Political motivations. Lawmakers approved the law, in part, to reinforce a $700 million federal Race To The Top grant, according to the legislative analysis. Districts will use half that grant to design, implement and fund the first three years of their performance pay systems.
  5. The goal. Reformers believe boosting pay will draw better quality teachers to the field, and that better teachers will produce better student results.

Latest Posts

Florida Schools Get ‘A Lot Of Flexibility’ Designing Teacher Evaluations

Teachers shouldn’t expect an apples-to-apples comparison when looking at new state-required evaluation scores. That’s because evaluations will vary — not just between charter schools and regular public schools — but between public school districts. Mike Kooi, Executive Director of the Office of Independent Education and Parental Choice, has been trying to set the record straight […]

Charter Schools Say Their Teachers Will Be Evaluated The Same As District Teachers

The way charter school teachers are evaluated has become a source of conflict for teachers and for lawmakers in Tallahassee. The question isn’t whether charter teachers have to be evaluated under state law – they do. Just like traditional public school teachers, they will eventually have to follow the standards set by the law passed […]

Florida Senate President Says Teachers Shouldn’t Expect An Even Playing Field

Supporters say the charter school bill that has a good chance of passing Florida’s Republican controlled Legislature this year will better regulate charters and expand choices for parents. One thing the bill won’t do is require the same evaluations for charter school teachers as traditional public school teachers. Charter schools which do not participate in […]

Challenge To Teacher Merit Pay Rule Underway In Tallahassee

A judge in Tallahassee is hearing a legal challenge to a state rule regarding teacher evaluations and merit pay. The Florida Legislature passed Senate Bill 736 last year, known as the “Student Success Act.” It sets standards for teacher evaluations and pay based on performance. Once the law went into effect last summer, state education […]

Read the Emails Between Suspended Hillsborough Teacher and Union Officials

A Hillsborough County high school teacher suspended last week over his objection to a new evaluation has apparently posted his emails with school and union officials online. Newsome High School teacher Joseph Thomas objected to a peer evaluator he believed did not have enough experience. The review is part of a new teacher evaluation system […]

Gaming the Merit Pay System

Teacher merit pay systems need less objectivity and more accountability if they are to work, argues an economist at the libertarian-leaning Cato Institute. Rating and paying teachers based on student test scores is unlikely to improve teachers, writes Arnold Kling. It is easier to “game” the system if it is based on a simple formula, […]

Five Things To Know About Florida’s New Education Requirements

The new teacher evaluations and merit pay plans school districts are rolling out this year that StateImpact Florida reported yesterday are just a portion of a broad education reform package lawmakers approved last spring. Here’s what to know about the Student Success Act, also known as Senate bill 736:

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »