Bringing the Economy Home


The Road To Idaho's Health Insurance Exchange


This page is no longer being updated. For ongoing coverage of this topic, go to Boise State Public Radio’s website.

Idaho’s state-run health insurance exchange is expected to begin enrollment by Oct. 1, 2013 and fully functional by Jan. 1, 2014. The exchange is an online marketplace where Idahoans will be able to shop for and purchase health insurance. The Idaho Legislature approved plans to build the exchange in March 2013, but two years of intense debate preceded the vote.

After the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the Obama Administration’s federal health care overhaul in 2012, two key decisions rested with states. One, should states expand Medicaid to include more people? Two, should states create their own health insurance exchanges?

Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter chose not to make a snap judgement, instead, he created a work group to study whether Idaho should create it’s own health insurance exchange, let the federal government create one for the state, or some combination of the two options.

Otter’s 14-member panel decided in October 2012 that Idaho should move forward with creating it’s own exchange. The governor followed suit, and Gov. Otter issued a statement on Dec. 11, 2012 that Idaho should create a state-based exchange.

Two Years Of Debate

The health insurance exchange debate has been ongoing ever since it became clear an exchange would be part of the federal health care reform package which was signed into law in 2010.

Because Idaho didn’t have the framework set up for a health insurance exchange, it was expected to be one of the biggest debates of the 2012 legislative session

The Associated Press held a special discussion of the issue during its January 2012 legislative preview. In a series of interviews that StateImpact conducted in December, legislator after legislator predicted it would be a defining issue of the months ahead.

Instead, it was more or less dead on arrival. Not even a plan developed by Sen. Dean Cameron (R-Rupert) and Rep. Fred Wood (R-Burley) for a stripped-down, state-run exchange could muster sufficient support.

Health insurance exchanges are a primary component of the Affordable Care Act. By their most basic description, exchanges are organizations — essentially online marketplaces — intended to make health insurance options more clear and, thereby, more competitive.

The underlying logic is this: individuals and small businesses don’t have perfect information or a great deal of bargaining power with insurers.  A health insurance exchange lays out the private and public health insurance options, explaining plans in terms of benefits and costs.

Under the Affordable Care Act, states can create their own exchanges or wait for the federal government to do it for them.

Rep. Wood says it was ideological opposition to the health care law that did in the prospects for a state-run exchange.  “I think there was a certain number of people that simply didn’t want anything to do with an exchange,” he said.  “And they were in a position that they could affect that outcome. In other words: no exchange.”

Wood, a retired physician and former director of the Cassia Regional Medical Center, believes state lawmakers are rolling the dice, hoping the federal health care law will be overturned.  “They’re betting that the Supreme Court will strike down the entire law,” he said. “And if we bet the wrong way, it could be very costly for the state.”

Costly because states creating their own exchanges will have some discretion to set the essential benefits that must be provided by insurers. But states falling under the federal plan likely won’t have that same flexibility. The Idaho Department of Insurance has predicted Idaho employers could expect to pay millions more in health care costs under a federal exchange.

Latest Posts

Gov. Otter Makes Another Plea With Idaho Lawmakers To Approve A Health Exchange

Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter is making another plea with Idaho House members to pass his state-based health insurance exchange bill. Last week, after nearly six hours of debate, the Idaho Senate passed Otter’s exchange plan 23-12. Now, the House will determine the fate of an Idaho-based, online health insurance marketplace. The debate is between Republican […]

After Intense Debate On Idaho’s Health Exchange, Some Humor

After six hours of debate over whether Idaho should build a state-based health insurance exchange, one lawmaker paused for a little levity. In his lukewarm support for the state-based exchange, Sen. Marv Hagedorn (R-Meridian) said, “I can’t ride this pig if it’s a federal exchange, I can ride it with spurs on if it’s a […]

Idaho’s State-Based Health Exchange Passes The Senate, Heads To House

After nearly six hours of debate, Idaho Senators voted 23-12 in favor of creating a state-based health insurance exchange. Exchanges, or online health insurance marketplaces, are a cornerstone of the federal health care law. According to The Kaiser Family Foundation, Idaho is one of 18 states with plans to create a state-based exchange. Twenty-six states […]

Debate Over An Idaho Health Insurance Exchange Heads Into Fifth Hour

The Idaho Senate is heading into its fifth hour of debate on a bill written by the governor’s office to create a state-based health insurance exchange. Afternoon committee meetings have been canceled. Debate stopped and started after a motion to send the proposal back to committee to be amended, and a motion to begin amending […]

State-Based Health Exchange Wins Conditional Support From 16 House Freshman

Sixteen Republican House members, all of them freshmen, this morning announced their support for a bill to create a state-based health insurance exchange. That bill, promoted by Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter and currently in the Senate, is one of the most controversial of the 2013 session. The first-year lawmakers constitute a key block of support, […]

Gov. Otter’s Health Insurance Exchange Plan Moves Forward

Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter’s health insurance exchange plan will move forward for a full vote in the Idaho Senate. Lawmakers on the Senate Commerce and Human Resources Committee spent more than 90 minutes listening to a second day of public testimony and debating the proposal before voting 8-1. The overriding theme: Idaho will be able […]

Idaho Republican Party Encourages Lawmakers To Reject Gov. Otter’s Health Exchange

Idaho Republican Party chairman Barry Peterson says the GOP’s position on creating a state-based health insurance exchange is “clear and irrefutable”. In advance of this afternoon’s Senate Commerce and Human Resources Committee vote on Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter’s health exchange proposal, the party sent this statement to media and lawmakers: The Idaho Republican Party today […]

Lobbying Efforts Heat Up As Idaho’s Health Insurance Exchange Hearing Is Scheduled

Idahoans will have a chance to weigh in on whether the state should create its own health insurance exchange tomorrow at the Capitol. The Senate Commerce and Human Resources Committee will spend Tuesday and Thursday hearing the health insurance exchange bill written by the Governor’s administration. Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter reversed course late last year […]

Gov. Otter’s Health Exchange Plan Clears First Hurdle In The Idaho Legislature

A panel of Idaho senators voted unanimously to give a full hearing to legislation that would create a state-based health insurance exchange. Gov. Otter’s chief of staff introduced the proposal to the Senate Commerce and Human Resources Committee today. It’s the first step toward creating an online insurance marketplace for Idaho. “It’s important to understand […]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »