Eye on Education


gold stars

Ohio’s School Accountability System: Understanding the Report Card


Ohio's Department of Education produces annual report cards for schools and school districts.

Legislation establishing Ohio’s school accountability system was passed in 1997, though the system has been revised extensively since including revisions to bring it into alignment with the federal No Child Left Behind Act.

Currently, the Ohio Department of Education analyzes performance data for schools and districts and rates them as Excellent with Distinction, Excellent, Effective, Continuous Improvement, Academic watch, or Academic Emergency. The data used to create those ratings include:

  • The percentage of students passing state tests;
  • How well students score on state tests;
  • For elementary and middle schools, a calculation showing how much progress students made in a particular school year;
  • Attendance rates;
  • High school graduation rates; and
  • Whether or not the school or district meets federal standards. (Those federal standards are called Adequate Yearly Progress and include reading and math test passing rates and test participation, attendance and graduation rates.)
What are the consequences of those ratings?

Schools and districts face varying consequences for failing to meet federal standards. But for the 2010-11 school year, there were few consequences tied to traditional public schools’ and districts’ report card ratings. (Charter schools already face sanctions for repeatedly receiving low grades from the state.) The consequences for traditional public schools will change in the coming years with provisions included in the 2011 biennial budget that require the Department of Education to rank schools and reward top performers and apply stricter sanctions to some schools with low grades.

Latest Posts

What the Ohio 2012 School Report Card Delay Means for Parents, Teachers and Communities

Doug Waldron / Flickr Ohio is delaying the release of school report cards indefinitely pending the outcome of a statewide investigation into whether some schools  manipulated student data to make their state report card grades look better. “The report cards are intended to give an accurate picture of how well schools are doing and they [...]

Why Three-Fourths of Ohio Schools Could See Their State Report Cards Downgraded


A new way of grading Ohio’s schools would mean fewer A-rated schools and more with Bs, Cs, Ds and Fs. Three-fourths of school districts and charter schools would see their state rating drop the equivalent of at least one grade if this new system is approved and they perform the same this year as last year.  (Scroll [...]

Stating the Obvious: Ohio’s Poor Students Still Not Doing as Well as Richer Counterparts

Judging by the Ohio Department of Education’s press release, Ohio schools are getting better and better year after year: The percentage of students scoring proficient on state tests increased on 21 of 26 indicators, with the strongest gains in third-grade math, eighth-grade math and 10th-grade writing. Overall, students met the state goal on 17 out [...]

The Media’s Up/Down Coverage of Ohio’s School Report Card Release

In Ohio, the annual release of school report cards is largely a local event, with media focusing on which districts in their coverage areas move up a rating or two and which move down. But some outlets focus on the bigger picture questions, like: How are charter schools doing? What’s up with the new graduation [...]

Why You Can’t Judge an Ohio School By Its Rating


Steve Snodgrass / Flickr As we noted earlier, the grades that the Ohio Department of Education awards public schools each year are a shorthand way of communicating a school’s performance. And within each rating, school performance can vary widely. If you think of those grades as letter grades on a student’s report card, here’s how [...]

Ohio Schools Chief Inserts a Giant “But” Into School Report Card Release

The Ohio school report cards released today presented a messaging challenge for state Superintendent Stan Heffner. Most of the ways that Ohio measures school performance are trending up. But compared to the ways that the state will judge school performance in a few years, doing well now is like skiing the bunny slope: Good for [...]

Your Questions About New School Accountabilty Law Answered

The state budget bill signed into law in June raises the stakes for low-performing public schools. Under one of the budget bill’s provisions, for the first time Ohio’s traditional public schools could be closed for poor performance, a sanction that previously only applied to Ohio charter schools. The new law requires the Ohio Department of [...]

Counting Ohio’s Homeschoolers: “We Don’t Know How Many”

Last week we shared the story of some families in Ohio that have chosen to homeschool their children, a trend that is on the rise here and around the country. But many of our readers took offense at the assertion by some that there is little oversight of homeschoolers. They say there is plenty of [...]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »