Eye on Education



Inside the Ohio School Data-Rigging Investigation


In late June 2012, Ohio Auditor of State Dave Yost began investigating whether staff at school districts across Ohio improperly changed student data to make their schools’ performance look better, particularly on state report cards. The auditor’s office is also looking at what role the Ohio Department of Education played in any improper data maniupation.

In October 2012, the FBI launched its own investigation.

As of Oct. 23, Yost had found evidence of “scrubbing” in five districts: Campbell (near Youngstown), Cleveland, Columbus, Marion City and Toledo. The Ohio Department of Education also found that the Lockland district near Cincinnati had engaged in scrubbing.

Yost defined scrubbing as “the practice of removing students from enrollment without lawful reason regardless of the purpose or purported motivation.” The auditor notes, “The term scrubbing does not always imply mal-intent.”

However, Yost has said that “interviews have produced evidence of ‘mal-intent’ behind the changing of student data in some school districts,” the Columbus Dispatch reports. The Dispatch reports that Yost has also said that ”it’s a reasonable conclusion that data was manipulated in Columbus public schools.”

How Common Is It?

Yost initially suggested that what he called “attendance report rigging” might be a systemic problem in Ohio. But in September 2012, he said most schools appear to be following the rules:

“We don’t have any belief that even most schools are involved with this,” he said, but his investigation to date has shown many different ways in which schools have manipulated their attendance data.

Yost also said that any data that was “bad,” or improperly manipulated, in 2011-12 was probably bad in previous years too.


The auditor’s investigation came as a result of a Columbus Dispatch story that reported that the Columbus schools “retroactively alter thousands of student-attendance records at the end of each school year, casting doubt on the accuracy of the district’s state report card.”

The Toledo school district superintendent subsequently told the Toledo Blade that the district had manipulated some students’ attendance data to improve its state report card performance.

And in July, the Ohio Department of Education said that officials in the 600-student Lockland school district near Cincinnati “falsely reported 36 students as withdrawn during the school year, thereby removing them from the district’s state testing results.” After discovering the withdrawals, the department lowered he Lockland district’s state grade from a “B” to a “C.”

The existence of data manipulation isn’t a new thing: In 2008, the Cleveland Plain Dealer reported that the test scores of thousands of Ohio public-school students were removed from the calculations that make up districts report cards.

School Report Cards

The Ohio Department of Education delayed the release of 2012 school and district report cards due to the the state auditor’s investigation. The department released report cards for traditional public and charter schools and school districts in October, about two months after the report cards’ originally scheduled release.

Latest Posts

Former Columbus Superintendent Avoids Jail In Data Scandal


Tom Borgerding / WOSU The highest ranking public official convicted in the Columbus City Schools’ data rigging scandal will not do any jail time. Superintendent Gene Harris was meted a suspended sentence on charges of dereliction of duty. Harris’ 37 year career as an educator ended with a suspended jail term, revocation of her teacher [...]

Handling of Student Data Still An Issue in Columbus Schools

A new internal audit by Columbus City Schools found administrators continued marking students as having withdrawn without providing proper documentation, well after the superintendent vowed the practice would stop. The audit is a follow-up to one in 2012 that found school administrators improperly altered attendance data with the intention of inflating performance on state report [...]

Auditor Says “Bunker” Culture Led to Data Scrubbing in Columbus Schools

magnifying glass Auntie P

AUNTIE P. / FLICKR Data scrubbing in the Columbus City Schools went far beyond manipulating attendance data to inflate the district’s standing on the 2010-2011 report card. The report released from State Auditor Dave Yost today shows administrators repeatedly changed student grades from an “F” to a “D”, listed seniors on the books who weren’t enrolled, [...]

Columbus Board Weighs Changes To ‘Policy Governance’

As state auditors wrap up their investigation into alleged data rigging in the Columbus City Schools, the district is set to make big changes on how it’s run. The new president of the Columbus school board promises to shake things up and increase scrutiny of the district’s budget and academic performance. In the early 2000′s, [...]

Columbus School District Could Face State Takeover For Data Scrubbing

chairs in rows

The Columbus school district could face state takeover because it improperly altered student records, if a provision inserted into the state budget is approved. The amendment (starting on p. 248) allows the state superintendent to “establish an academic distress commission for any school district that is found by the Auditor of State to have knowingly manipulated [...]

Cleveland Schools CEO: No Evidence of Wrongdoing in Cleveland Data Scrubbing

Cleveland school district CEO Eric Gordon said yesterday the state auditor has found “no evidence of intentional wrongdoing” in its audit of the Cleveland school district’s attendance records. But the Cleveland school district’s past attendance records are still unable to be audited, meaning it’s impossible to confirm that the district followed state attendance laws.

The Top 10 Ohio Education Stories of 2012

Blue number ten 10

Whether you call it reform, revolution, transformation or transmutation, the pace of change in the world of Ohio education continues to speed up. As we move into what’s likely to be another year of change in Ohio schools, we’ve whittled things down to this list of the 10 biggest Ohio education stories of 2012. 1. [...]

Auditor: Criminal Charges Likely In Columbus Schools Data Rigging Investigation

Columbus school district employees may face criminal charges in connection with unlawfully manipulating student data to make schools’ performance look better, says William Owen, the chief attorney for State Auditor David Yost. But employees at other school districts being investigated for similar actions are not likely to face criminal charges. Owen says the investigation into [...]

Columbus School Superintendent Gene Harris to Retire (Updated)

Columbus school district Superintendent Gene Harris will announce her retirement this afternoon, our partners at WOSU report: A source confirms Harris will retire following several months in the spotlight amid allegations of attendance rigging. The retirement will not be immediately, however. Harris will leave at the end of the school year. Her retirement comes as the [...]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »