Eye on Education



Ohio's SB 5, Explained


J.D. Pooley / Getty Imanges

Protesters against Senate Bill 5 display make their way into the Statehouse during a February 2011 rally in Columbus, Ohio.

Senate Bill 5 (SB 5) was signed into law on March 31, 2011, by Governor John Kasich. It limited collective bargaining for public employee unions. That meant police officers, firefighters, teachers, and other public employees would not have been able to negotiate for healthcare benefits or pensions costs, though they could still bargain over some areas. It also allowed public employers to not bargain over wages and contained an array of changes to Ohio’s current laws, including many changes affecting teachers and school districts.

After a statewide repeal campaign financed largely by labor unions, voters in the November 2011 general election supported repealing the law 62 percent to 38 percent.

SB 5 contained many changes to Ohio’s current laws. In regard to teachers and school districts in particular, SB 5 would:

  • Prohibit public employees from striking;
  • Prohibit employees of some charter schools from collectively bargaining;
  • Permit public employers to not bargain on subjects affecting wages, hours, and terms and conditions of employment;
  • Prohibit most public schools from entering into collective bargaining agreements that do certain things, such as establishing maximum class sizes;
  • Limit, for new collective bargaining agreements, sick leave payouts and the amounts of certain types of leave that can be accrued;
  • Eliminate statutory salary schedules and require performance-based pay for teachers based in part on student performance;
  • Limit public employer contributions toward health care benefit costs to 85 percent;
  • Eliminate the current rules about leave that apply to teachers and authorize each board of education to set its own leave policies;
  • Abolish continuing contracts for teachers, except for those continuing contracts in existence prior July 2011, and revise rules about limited contracts; and
  • Remove consideration of seniority and length of service, by itself, from decisions regarding layoffs.

J.D. Pooley / Getty Images

State Sen. Shannon Jones (R-OH), pictured during a February 22, 2011 senate committee hearing, introduced Senate Bill 5.

SB 5′s elimination of the annual “step” raises that teachers usually receive and its required creation of a performance pay system was put on hold pending the outcome of the November referendum and, with the November 2011 elections results, will not take effect. However, efforts to change how Ohio teachers are evaluated and paid continued to move forward under a separate piece of legislation.

House Bill 153, the main operating budget for the two fiscal years starting in July 2011, required the State Board of Education to develop a new teacher evaluation system under which half of a teacher’s rating would be based on student performance. HB 153 also required districts receiving Race to the Top money to use a teacher performance pay system based on that new teacher evaluation system.

Latest Posts

Six Ohio Education Stories to Watch in 2012

Ohio school districts to state: "Show me the money."

Here’s our take on the six education stories to watch in 2012: 1. School funding. School funding. School funding. Look for a new K-12 school funding model from Columbus in the first part of 2012. The previous model was scrapped in 2011, with the promise of a new formula for distributing state money to Ohio’s [...]

Top StateImpact Ohio Education Stories of 2011

StateImpact Ohio launched in June 2011 as your source for Ohio education news and analysis from NPR and Ohio public media. It’s been a big year for us, and for education in Ohio. How big? Let us count the ways: Issue 2 Gov. John Kasich signed Senate Bill 5 in March 2011. And the successful [...]

Issue 2 Inspires New Legislation from Both Sides of the Aisle

Leo Reynolds / Flickr Ohio Gov. John Kasich may have decided he’ll “take a deep breath” before making any new moves on limiting the state’s public employees’ collective bargaining rights after voters resoundingly rejected Issue 2. But politics isn’t known for being patient. It seems neither side of the aisle wanted to get left behind, [...]

Lessons from Issue 2′s Defeat: Fantasy Worlds, Insanity and Targeting Teachers

Senate Bill 5, a law limiting collective bargaining for Ohio’s public sector employees, will be repealed after a referendum on the law, Issue 2, was defeated in this week’s general election. What can we read into the defeat? Depending on who you talk to, it’s either a sign that legislators should try again on the [...]

Ohioans Opted to Stick with the Status Quo on Election Day

Ohioans sent some mixed messages this Election Day. They voted against the federal health care overhaul and turned down many school levies, but they also showed overwhelming support for public employee unions. This kind of voting isn’t unique in Ohio.   There’s a reason Ohio is a significant swing state. No president has gotten to [...]

Issue 2 Defeat May Play Key Role in 2012 Presidential Elections

Teachers, fire fighters, police officers, and other public employees spent much of last night celebrating. Their victory could extend well beyond last night. The presidential elections are just about a year away, and Ohio’s Issue 2 could play a key role in that race. Paul Sracic, chair of the political science department at Youngstown State [...]

Maps Compare Ohio County-by-County Issue 2 Results to 2010 Gubernatorial Race

Click on the map to see how Issue 2 results compare to 2010 gubernatorial election results.

Ohio Gov. John Kasich was front and center selling Issue 2 in the weeks leading up to the November general election, even starring in a video encouraging Ohioans to get out and vote “yes” on Issue 2 released the morning of election day. Issue 2 failed by a 2-1 margin, meaning that collective bargaining law [...]

Unions Celebrate Victory Over Issue 2

In an election watched nationwide, Ohio’s voters quashed Issue 2 last night. That’s the measure that would have limited collective bargaining for some 350-thousand police, firefighters, teachers and other public employees. Unions members celebrated last night, but many are already concerned about Governor John Kasich’s next move. The “We Are Ohio” watch party in Cleveland [...]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »