Eye on Education



The Essentials of Teacher Performance Pay in Ohio


Ohio policymakers including Gov. John Kasich and GOP lawmakers want to move the current system of basing teacher pay and layoffs on seniority to one under which they’re tied to classroom performance.

Senate Bill 5
would have replaced the current system of paying teachers based on their educational credentials and years of employment to one under which teachers’ pay would be tied to their performance and behavior. However, SB 5 was repealed by voters and never took effect.

The 2011 biennial budget, known as House Bill 153, also includes a performance pay provision. It requires school districts receiving federal Race to the Top funds that said they were going to include performance pay in their plans for using the funds to go ahead and do so. The Ohio Department of Education strongly encourages school districts that did not include performance pay in their plans for the federal funding to implement performance pay for teachers, but does not require them to do so.

Some Ohio school districts, including Cleveland, are already trying out pilot versions of performance pay systems.

Latest Posts

Grading the Teachers: Performance Isn’t Reflected in Teachers’ Paychecks

Students in Emily Brown’s Toledo classroom conduct an experiment on the movement of waves. While she drops a block of clay into an aluminum tray filled with water and watches the waves spread out, 7th grader Angel Hines explains why she likes Mrs. Brown. “She actually lets us grade her so she knows if she’s [...]

Grading the Teachers: Little Connection Between Teacher Pay and Performance

Ray Fatur, who has been teaching for 19 years, says paying experienced teachers more just make sense.

There is little connection between how much money Ohio teachers make and how much knowledge they impart to students over the course of a single year, according to a StateImpact Ohio/Plain Dealer analysis of a new measure of teacher performance. In fact, that analysis of state data shows that within many school districts, teachers who [...]

Cleveland School District Moves Towards Performance Pay

Last night the Cleveland school board unanimously agreed to what city and union officials are hailing as a groundbreaking teacher contract for Ohio. Union members will vote later this month. The contract spells out a new basis for teacher pay hikes. Raises merely for lasting another year in the job are out; so are automatic [...]

The Five Things Ohio Teachers Worry About

After holding 18 meetings with Ohio teachers and reviewing about 1,300 of emails, Ohio Teacher Liaison Sarah Dove presents in this draft document the five main areas of concern teachers have about coming changes to the ways teachers are evaluated and paid. Take look at the word cloud below. The big takeaway: “Teachers need…”

How Ohio’s Teacher Liaison Separates the Personal from the Professional

In what she calls her “personal role”, Ohio teacher liaison and former Kasich campaign worker Sarah Dove is a supporter of Senate Bill 5, the law that would limit collective bargaining and replace salary ladders with performance pay, among other things. Unless you’ve been living under a rock for the past few months, you probably [...]

Performance Pay for Teachers Was a Big Deal Twenty Years Ago

Education Week’s interactive timeline digs into the publication’s archives to show the sweep of education policy changes through the years, from the Reagan era on forward. One example, from May 1983: “A dramatic move by President Reagan to “seize the educational initiative” has made teacher pay central in a partisan political debate and has prompted [...]

Meet Ohio Gov. John Kasich’s Chosen Teacher

Ohio Department of Education Senior Policy Director Sarah Dove.

“I disagree with so much of what OEA says and does. I can’t imagine them taking even one more penny from my paycheck.” That’s a Facebook post from Ohio’s new teacher liaison, an elementary teacher from Gahanna named Sarah Dove who has been charged with reaching out to educators across the state to get their [...]

Teacher Performance Pay Happens at the College Level Too

With efforts to introduce performance pay for K-12 teachers into Ohio schools, we thought it would be worth taking a look at how another type of teacher–the college professor–is evaluated and paid. Teaching fourth grade math isn’t the same as teaching a freshman English class, much less doing academic research. But this overview of Ohio [...]

New York City Ends Performance Pay Program

As some Ohio schools move towards paying teachers based on their performance in the classroom, one big city district is ending its teacher performance bonus program. The New York City Department of Education will shut down the program that distributed $56 million in performance bonuses to teachers and other school staff members over the last [...]

Lessons on Performance Pay from the Private Sector

Performance pay may be a new concept for Ohio teachers, but not for many of the state’s private-sector workers. Those who have lived with merit pay for years says the keys to making it work include picking the right performance measures, ensuring employees trust the system and preparing managers to spend quality time doing evaluations. [...]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »