Eye on Education


The defeat of Issue 2 in November 2011 meant that collective bargaining law Senate Bill 5 was repealed.

A Guide to Ohio's Issue 2, the Item Formerly Known as the SB 5 Referendum


[Looking for information about Issue 2, the redistricting proposal on the fall 2012 ballot? Click here.]

In fall 2011, voters weighed in on a referendum on Senate Bill 5, Ohio’s anti-collective bargaining law. The referendum was the second issue on the ballot, and was titled Issue 2. (Issue 1 dealt with a constitutional amendment increasing the age limit for judges; Issue 3 was on a constitutional amendment barring laws that require anyone to participate in a health-care system.)

Voters supported repealing the law by about a 2-to-1 margin.

SB 5 would have limited collective bargaining for public employee unions. That means police officers, firefighters, teachers, and other public employees would not have been able to negotiate for health care benefits or pension costs, though they could still bargain over some areas. It also allowed public employers to not bargain over wages and contained an array of changes to Ohio’s current laws, including many changes affecting teachers and school districts.

Those changes included eliminating statutory salary schedules; limiting employer contributions towards health insurance to 85 percent; abolishing new continuing contracts (tenure); and removing consideration of seniority and length of service, by itself, from decisions regarding layoffs.

As written, SB 5 would have taken effect on July 1, 2011. However, it was suspended pending the outcome of the referendum and, with the November election results, will now never be enacted.

The state’s public-sector unions mounted a statewide campaign to repeal SB 5. The campaign pitted public-sector unions fighting for their survival in Ohio and other states against Ohio Gov. John Kasich and other cost-cutting Republican officials.

The successful repeal effort could be seen as a victory for public-sector employee unions fighting to protect their ability to bargain for wages and benefits and a blow to Gov. John Kasich and others who were hoping to reduce government spending and the unions’ power.

The way that Issue 2 appeared on the November 2011 ballot made a “no” vote a vote to repeal SB 5 and a “yes” vote a vote to keep the law in place.

Latest Posts

Lessons from Issue 2′s Defeat: Fantasy Worlds, Insanity and Targeting Teachers

Senate Bill 5, a law limiting collective bargaining for Ohio’s public sector employees, will be repealed after a referendum on the law, Issue 2, was defeated in this week’s general election. What can we read into the defeat? Depending on who you talk to, it’s either a sign that legislators should try again on the [...]

Ohioans Opted to Stick with the Status Quo on Election Day

Ohioans sent some mixed messages this Election Day. They voted against the federal health care overhaul and turned down many school levies, but they also showed overwhelming support for public employee unions. This kind of voting isn’t unique in Ohio.   There’s a reason Ohio is a significant swing state. No president has gotten to [...]

Issue 2 Defeat May Play Key Role in 2012 Presidential Elections

Teachers, fire fighters, police officers, and other public employees spent much of last night celebrating. Their victory could extend well beyond last night. The presidential elections are just about a year away, and Ohio’s Issue 2 could play a key role in that race. Paul Sracic, chair of the political science department at Youngstown State [...]

Maps Compare Ohio County-by-County Issue 2 Results to 2010 Gubernatorial Race

Click on the map to see how Issue 2 results compare to 2010 gubernatorial election results.

Ohio Gov. John Kasich was front and center selling Issue 2 in the weeks leading up to the November general election, even starring in a video encouraging Ohioans to get out and vote “yes” on Issue 2 released the morning of election day. Issue 2 failed by a 2-1 margin, meaning that collective bargaining law [...]

Unions Celebrate Victory Over Issue 2

In an election watched nationwide, Ohio’s voters quashed Issue 2 last night. That’s the measure that would have limited collective bargaining for some 350-thousand police, firefighters, teachers and other public employees. Unions members celebrated last night, but many are already concerned about Governor John Kasich’s next move. The “We Are Ohio” watch party in Cleveland [...]

Early Results in Ohio Suggest Labor Will Win on Issue 2

Early results from less than 10 of Ohio’s 88 counties suggest that Issue 2, a referendum on a law that would significantly weaken Ohio’s public employee unions, is headed for repeal. Of the 125,000 votes counted thus far, 67 percent were in favor of repealing Senate Bill 5. The early results echo polls showing most [...]

How Issue 2 Would Make Ohio’s Schools More Like Florida’s

Our colleagues at StateImpact Florida report that if Issue 2 passes, it would allow Ohio to do a lot of things Florida has already done. Earlier this year, Gov. Rick Scott (who, like Gov. John Kasich, was then a newly elected Republican governor) signed SB 736. The law, which is being challenged in court, rewrote [...]

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »