The federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration has wrapped up its investigation into the death of a worker at a Chevron natural gas well site in southwest Pennsylvania. The agency announced in a brief statement Tuesday it will not issue citations or fines for the incident.
On Feb. 11, Ian McKee, 27, was killed when a well exploded in Dunkard Township, Greene County. McKee was a contractor with Houston-based Cameron International.
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection recently concluded that the fire was caused by an inexperienced contract worker who did not properly tighten a bolt and locknut assembly on the wellhead, allowing methane to escape and eventually ignite. State investigators found workers on the site were improperly supervised by Chevron.
OSHA said it could not determine the exact cause of the incident.
Here’s the agency’s full statement:
The U.S. Department of Labor’s Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) responded immediately to investigate the workplace fatality that occurred on Feb. 11, 2014, at the Lanco well site located in Greene County, Pa., and operated by Chevron Appalachia, LLC. At the conclusion of an in-depth, six-month investigation, OSHA determined that no citations would be issued, and concluded that the exact cause of the incident could not be determined. As is routine in such investigations, OSHA involved the victim’s family both during its probe and afterwards, to explain the agency’s findings and any actions that could be taken.
On any given day Bob Deering doesn’t know how much trouble he’ll have getting to and from his home. He lives on a mountain in Lycoming County and he’s routinely stopped and questioned by security guards. It’s been happening for the past six years– ever since the natural gas boom began.
“I’ve been coming up here with my grandparents since 1953,” he says. “But if I would have known in 2001 what I know now, I’d never have built a house up here.”
Deering expected to enjoy a quiet retirement. In the early 2000′s, he and his wife built a log home from a kit. Their property is surrounded by state forest and game land.
But in recent years their neighborhood has gotten noisy as gas companies drill wells, build pipelines, and move heavy equipment.
Nearly a third of Pennsylvania’s roughly 2 million acres of public forest land is already available for oil and gas development. Governor Corbett wants to lease even more land, but an environmental group is suing to try to stop him.
Southwestern Energy Production company will have to pay $128,031 for drilling five unpermitted Marcellus Shale gas wells in Bradford County. The state Department of Environmental Protection announced the fine today after the Houston, Texas company continued to drill even after the DEP issued a “notice of violation” in January 2013.
A DEP investigation revealed that Southwestern had drilled at the Reeve Sutton 4H well pad in Herrick Township, Bradford County for nine days in October 2012, about 18 months past the permit’s expiration date. The department issued notice of violation (NOV) letters for this unpermitted drilling to Southwestern in January 2013.
Southwestern committed the same violations at four other wells in Bradford County in October 2012 and February 2013, conducting drilling four to 16 months after permits had expired. Two of the four wells were drilled after the company received the NOVs from the department in January 2013.
A gas drilling permit lasts for one year. If drilling does not begin within that year, the company has to apply for a new permit.
A natural gas extraction tax in Pennsylvania has been regarded at times as a silver bullet, and lawmakers have proposed shooting it every which way to solve financial woes. Perhaps it was only a matter of time before someone suggested aiming it at the state’s pension problems.
A natural gas drilling tax was considered by state lawmakers as recently as June and but it was jettisoned due to lack of support among Republicans.
Democrats have been full-throated supporters of an extraction tax, but Democratic Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa said they would want to spend the money differently, “the bulk of it going to education.”
Lancaster Newspapers reports a crew of pipeline surveyors trespassed on at least five properties in Lancaster County. The surveyors were contractors for the pipeline company Williams, which has now banned the workers from this and all future projects, according to a spokeswoman.
Five landowners spoke about the incidents in a press conference last night in Martic Township.
Each said their property is posted with “no trespassing” signs and none had given Williams permission to be on their property.
The gathering, organized by the citizens’ group Lancaster Against Pipelines, was held in the Venture Drive backyard of Tracey McVey.
McVey said she came home from work Tuesday afternoon to see three men in orange vests standing at the edge of her yard. When questioned, they told her they were surveying for the proposed pipeline.
When told they were trespassing, they took a step backward and told her “We’re now not on your property.”
Williams spokeswoman Cindy Ivey told Lancaster Newspapers in an email that the company has “an established procedure to review survey plans for each week.” The procedure includes a review of which property owners that have and have not given permission for surveyors to do their work.
“This particular crew did not follow our established procedures and has been relieved of their duties,” Ivey wrote. “They will not be allowed to return to the project or work on any other Williams’ project.”
Paul Woods, left, and David Manthos with the nonprofit SkyTruth check out results from their data-scraping bot at their office in Shepherdstown, West Virginia. SkyTruth says the chemical disclosure website FracFocus is flawed.
The website FracFocus.org was built to give the public answers to a burning question about the shale boom: what exactly were companies pumping down tens of thousands of wells to release oil and gas?
Today, FracFocus has records for more than 77,000 wells. Pennsylvania is one of 14 states requiring operators to use the website as part of their chemical disclosure laws, according to the U.S. Department of Energy.
However, transparency about those chemicals remains elusive.
State investigators have determined that human error may have led to a fatal explosion on a well pad in Dunkard Township, Greene County in February.
In a new report out today, the Department of Environmental Protection says Chevron was “too guarded” in its communication with state regulators and the media, and did not provide adequate information after a fatal well fire in southwest Pennsylvania.
The DEP admits it is also to blame for the poor communication and that the agency did not immediately assert its authority following the incident in February.
A second report by the department’s Bureau of Investigations faults Chevron’s site managers for inadequate supervision over several contractors working on the Lanco A well pad in Dunkard Township, Greene County.
DEP investigators found the explosion was likely caused by an inexperienced contractor – known as a “greenhat” – who was sent to assist a more experienced worker in preparing to put the three wells on the pad into production. The agency determined the unnamed greenhat did not properly tighten a bolt and locknut assembly on one of the wellheads, allowing gas to escape and eventually ignite.
“Our investigation revealed that the oversight of that operation was somewhat less than it should have been,” said DEP spokesman John Poister.
A contract worker, 27-year-old Ian McKee, was killed in the fire on Feb. 11.
PPL has not proposed an official route yet, but this graphic shows the rough outlines of where the power line would go.
PPL Electric Utilities is looking to build a new multi-billion dollar transmission line to keep up with natural gas production in the Marcellus Shale and the changing landscape of power generation.
If approved by regulators, the high-voltage power line is still a decade away but PPL has started planning.
The transmission line would start in Western Pennsylvania and run 725 miles through the state’s Northern Tier, into New Jersey and New York, as well as southward into Maryland.
The project would cost between $4 and 6 billion, according to PPL spokesman Paul Wirth.
“The gas industry is one of the impetuses behind it,” he says. “The other is that by starting in Western Pennsylvania we can bring existing supplies of lower-cost power—fueled by renewables and other sources—into this region.”
Alisa Lykens has been with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for 24 years and says she’s never seen such a big response to a project so early on in the process.
Lykens was at Millersville University in Lancaster County Monday night. It was the first in a series of four meetings hosted by FERC to take public comments on a proposed interstate natural gas pipeline that would go through ten Pennsylvania counties.
“This is sort of unprecedented, at least in my experience,” Lykens says. “But it’s not surprising. We see there’s a lot of concern and that’s why we’re here.”
More than 300 people showed up, and many spoke out against the pipeline and voiced concerns about how it would affect property values, safety, and the environment.
Mark Clatterbuck was among them. His property could be affected by one of the proposed routes, and he wants FERC to try to quantify the intense public opposition in its analysis of the project.
“I’m just asking them to find a way to measure that,” he says. “Don’t just ignore this issue because it feels slippery.”
The 189 mile pipeline is part of a larger effort –called the Atlantic Sunrise project– from Oklahoma-based Williams Partners to bring Marcellus Shale gas southward to markets in the Mid-Atlantic and southern United States.