Pennsylvania

Energy. Environment. Economy.

Township Supervisors Seek Stricter Regulation of Disposal Wells

Susan Phillips / StateImpact Pennsylvania

This former gas well in Warren County was permitted by the EPA to be converted to a disposal well. Local residents are fighting it.

The head of the state’s township supervisor’s lobbying organization has come out in favor of greater regulation of deep injection wells. David Sanko, executive director of the Pennsylvania State Association of Townhip Supervisors, recently wrote a letter to Gov. Corbett asking him to adopt measures similar to the state of Ohio.

Deep injection wells that are categorized as Class II take oil and gas wastewater, and dispose of it deep within the earth. Pennsylvania has only six of these wells operating, but several new permits are pending. The EPA oversees permitting of deep injection wells in the state.

After a deep injection well in Youngstown, Ohio caused several earthquakes over the Christmas holidays, Ohio took steps to monitor for seismic activity, reduce injection pressure, and require automatic shut-off devices.

In his letter to Corbett, Sanko says the increase in gas drilling will likely lead to an increase in deep injection wells, and he worries that the EPA is not up to the task of properly permitting these projects.

“In addition, EPA’s recent finding that EPA Region III failed to satisfy its responsibility to ensure the public that it relied on appropriate data as to drinking water wells in the area of proposed Class II injection wells in Columbus Township, Warren County serves to highlight the necessity and importance of ensuring that the Class II wells located in the Commonwealth are adequately regulated.”

Last month, the Environmental Hearing Board in Washington, D.C., rejected a permit for two new deep injection wells in Warren County. The Board told EPA Region 3 they did an inadequate job in surveying drinking water wells in the area. A group of residents worried about potential ground water pollution had appealed the permit.

The state now has six permitted, but only five operating wells. The EPA temporarily shut down one disposal well in Clearfield County after learning of a blow-out several months later.

Although the state has deferred jurisdiction over deep injection wells to federal regulators, Sanko wants Gov. Corbett to ask the EPA to adopt the rules now in use in Ohio. State Rep. Camille “Bud” George, a Democrat from Clearfield County, has introduced legislation to impose a moratorium on all new deep injection wells. But the bill is now stalled in committee.

Comments

  • schlumberjay

    Currently, there are five operational injection wells in PA. All of them are permitted (EPA/UIC Class IID) as “non-commercial” or “private” (which means the owner can only dispose of his/her O&G wastes, and not accept wastes from other E&P firms). Earlier this year there were three permitted (EPA/UIC Class IID) “commercial” injection wells in Pennsylvania (one of which recently failed and was plugged and abandoned by the owner). The well in the photo above (drilled and completed in 1983) and it’s younger brother (¼-mile to the north) are not yet operational, but are, at this time, the ONLY two permitted “commercial” injection well facilities in Pennsylvania (paste: 41.994008,-79.541434 into a Google Maps search window to see this well’s location). Some might ask what the failure rate for these type wells (UIC Commercial Class IID) in Pennsylvania, New York, and Ohio actually is (try doing a FOI Request to EPA or a RTKL Request to DEP for this), and why so many more new injection wells are needed when the industry is said (esp. by DEP Secretary Karncer) to be recycling such huge volumes of it’s flowback fluid and produced “water”. Once again the political arts trump science and law.

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Education