Florida

Putting Education Reform To The Test

What Students, Teachers do During the Final Days of Class

Sarah Gonzalez / StateImpact Florida

Shamika Jeff, posing with her younger brother, graduated from Miami Central High School on June 5, 2012. The 18-year-old says she did not go to the entire last week of school.

Florida students have already taken all the big tests. They’ve finished their homework. But some students are still in school.

So what do teachers and students do during the final days of class?

Educators throughout Florida say teaching should be going on every day students are in school.

But students say that isn’t usually what happens.

“In class I just hang out with friends and just remember all the memories that we had,” says Sophonie Pierre, a 7th grader at Plantation Middle School in Broward County.

“Our teachers they just let us enjoy it and talk.”

Graduating senior Shamika Jeff says she didn’t show up for the entire last week of school at Miami Central High School.

“There was no point in going,” she says. “Because you had already gotten your exit card and they gave you all your credits, so there was no point.”

Tangela Mitchell is a 9th grade intensive reading teacher at Miami Central High School.

“I don’t think I would have been able to pass if it wasn’t for that week.”

-Anthony Gutierrez, graduating class of 2012

She says “There should be instruction going on up until the last day.”

But she admits some teachers close out their grade books early.

Mitchell says teachers have to turn in all their student grades one day after the last day of class.

“For us to meet the deadline, some of us have closed them out,” she says. “However we would not express that to the kids because then they would think ‘What is the point?’”

But students are catching on anyway.

Seventh grader Pierre says it’s not fair that she has to go to class if teachers aren’t grading students anymore.

“We’re done with final exams,” she says. “Summer should begin already.”

Teachers like Mitchell say closing grade books early doesn’t mean teachers stop teaching.

“I will admit it takes some finagling to keep the kids motivated and instill in them that the importance of education is not just in a grade book,” she says.

She says students can watch educational films or give classroom presentations.

Mitchell says part of the problem is that students take the end-of-the-year Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test exams too early.

“It’s so difficult to get them to work beyond that moment, because what is the end of the year exam? It’s the end of the year,” she says.

“If we put things in place that symbolize that then it puts your educators in a place where it’s difficult to keep the kids rallied.”

Is it Time to Re-Think the School Calendar?

Some teachers say maybe school should be more like college.

You take your final exams and you’re done.

“We’ve always worked to test as late in the year as possible,” says Jamie Mongiovi with the Florida Department of Education.

She says FCAT tests can’t take place on the very last days of school because the state needs time to score the tests before students go on summer break.

Florida law requires that FCAT results are reported by June 8 of every year.

Candy Olson is chair of the Hillsborough County school board.

Sarah Gonzalez / StateImpact Florida

Anthony Gutierrez says there wasn't much class instruction during the last week of school, which allowed him to turn in make up work he needed to graduate.

She says it’s good for students to have some time to wind down at the end of the year to sign yearbooks and talk about their summer plans.

“I think it’s important for school not to be this grim death march to the end,” she says.

“We’re human beings we need to say our farewells. We need to celebrate. But I don’t think that’s an inappropriate use of school time or of taxpayer dollars.”

But the last week of school was more than a time to celebrate for senior Anthony Gutierrez.

“It was kind of hectic for me,” he says.

Gutierrez was failing math and was close to not graduating.

He used the last week to get extra help from teachers and turn in make-up work.

“I don’t think I would have been able to pass if it wasn’t for that week,” he says.

Comments

  • Doarhe

    for the first time in the 19 years I’ve been a teacher in a Florida Public school, this has happened.  Up to last year, the last three days were dedicated to final exams.  Students would take their last test, in the last period of the last day, they would leave school around noon and we would remain in school grading tests, cleaning rooms, setting up for the following year.  This year, FOR THE FIRST TIME, due to the avalanche of tests students face (March through May there is some test EVERY SINGLE DAY) it was decided to eliminate finals and midterms.  That’s why there was this wasted downtime this year, FOR THE FIRST TIME in 19 years at least that I can personally say.  I am baffled by how the public bashes teachers for not doing their job, how Public Education is under attack and reports like this don’t help.  Please, ask for what has happened before and what’s going on now.  Don’t just limit yourselves with reporting the apparent reality without goind deeper and finding out the reasons behind the appearances.  Now, more than ever Public Education needs to be taken VERY SERIOUSLY.  One of the pilars of our society, an efficient free, public access to education is about to crumble, and with it the society we know today.

  • Puffy

    Hey, why sweat it?  In 2009 U.S. high school students ranked 25th out of 35 countries in math and 17th out of 30 countries in science.  That should be good enough, right?  Mitt Romney just commented that a majority of Americans think we have too many overpriced teachers anyway.  Why should public school teachers be paid more than fast food restaurant managers.

    • Mark Pachankis

      in Europe, they dual track students. Only students who test high enough go on college track, and those students are compared to ours. If we did the same, our rankings would go up.

      • Doarhe

        Exactly!  In Asia, specially China, only the elite continues to higher grades and students have all sorts of tutors, paid by parents or the state.  Finally someone says something about this. It’s incredible how news media can be so insular as not to know what’s going on in the rest of the world. They just throw these numbers , they go unquestioned and then our system gets unjustly bashed.  

    • Robin Reads

      Before you decide how much I should or should not be paid, please come spend a week in my shoes. I worked many different types of jobs putting myself through school. They all have their own set of difficulties. Teaching is the only one where what I say and do may affect a persons life. Teaching is the only one where if I get a flat tire I call school before auto club, because my students can’t be left standing outside the door. Teaching is the only one where I don’t dive under a table during an earthquake until I make absolutely certain my students are safe. Teaching is the only one where I can’t go to the bathroom when I want, I can’t finish my 28 minute lunch at my desk, I have to worry that any injury I see on my students might represent abuse. So please, before you compare my job to any other, spend a week in my classroom. Just because you went to school, doesn’t mean you know my job.

      • Artsmartbabe

         Um, I think Puffy was being facetious….

  • Robin Reads

    We spend all year hyping the importance of the state tests. The kids work (mostly) hard during the 3 week testing period. And then,it is May 25,  the tests are over and we are left with 5 weeks of school. True as teachers we are pretty tired, but the kids are beyond tired. They constantly ask why they have to do school work if the test is over. The question is sincere, we push the tests so hard that all else seems unimportant. It is very hard to be in a room with 30 middle school students who have decided they don’t need to work. Trying to teach the remaining curriculum, keep them entertained if possible and try not to let them push the many buttons they have spent a school year installing is exhausting and frustrating. I love my “kids” and we have a great relationship, but oh how we all long for summer!

  • Trenalg

    Their last day should be a big, fun celebration.  But the days prior to that, if they’re not receiving instruction, what is it? Babysitting?  Why can’t they just get out, and come back for the celebration day?  I suspect it’s because the schools get x-numbers of dollars from gov’t. for each day they keep the kids penned up in school.  Pathetic.  Let ‘em go!
       Or better…they could be reading, and in small discussion groups.  Reading essays, then discussing them.  Writing essays, then discussing them together.  On topics of interest, some chosen by the teachers, some chosen by the kids.

  • Boyelynn

    This is really an administrative scheduling issue.  In this article they state that the state of Florida requires scores by a certain date, because of this the schools will have to require teachers to submit them by an earlier date for organization and cross-checking.  If there isn’t enough time set in the teacher’s contracts to allow them time to work and submit after the school year is complete, or the school calendar ends after the administrative deadline, then teachers are in a bind.

    I completely agree that the last day should be a celebration.  There are real benefits to allowing people the ability to relax and unwind, to reminisce and make plans for the future; it’s community building.

    I think that governmental bodies are often so caught up in ensuring that the public’s money is properly spent, that they don’t realize or recognize where their own rules put restrictions on the bureaucracies they administer.  In this case, it seems as if the calendar for the schools, the testing dates, and the contract calendar for the teachers are combining poorly.  The change really belongs at the highest levels in determining what process is necessary to allow the testing to be completed during that final week of school, and still allow the teachers time to grade and report properly. 

  • KateLR

    Here in Arkansas the state standardized test is given in APRIL! Since we spend the year teaching “to the Test”, of course the students think school is over when the test is over. Sadly, school has become a test prep factory, and little else.

  • jackie

    I see that this is a Florida based article, but the I’m sure that in most states you have pre-test and post-test performance indicators assigned to each state standard that still require teaching.  The post test performance indicators are often the hardest to teach because as is stated here, the kids think that school is over.  It is difficult to motivate kids to the reality that school is not over, their are topics they are required to learn that we are required to teach. 

    I wish that before people would continue to get so snippy they could realize what a social problem this is.  For some of us, we would never have dreamed of having such an attitude so blatantly displayed as students, but the world now is a different, harsher place and the world allows/teaches children to behave so poorly – we battle this all day, every day, in our classrooms.  And yes, I often invite people to come into my classroom for one week and see what life for a city, public school teacher is like these days – no one has taken me up on the offer in a long time.

  • Iowa Mom

    I think the Florida legislators have gotten so caught up in tests that “test performance” has taken priority over learning.  For Iowa high school students, we have the Iowa Tests of Educational Development, which are administered locally.  Our son’s high school principal moved them from the fall to the spring (April) this year at his school.  The tests assess what the students know, and, to some degree, if the curriculum needs adjustment.  A student’s advancement does not depend upon his score, it is used to see their weaknesses and strengths.  Seniors do not take the tests.  For (most of them), the AP tests are their big test(s).

  • LocalTrollUnion47

    It’s kind of cute that people think their comments on these topics have an impact. No one but other losers read them. Welcome to my world… the world of mom’s basement, and the stench of 5-day old underwear, and abject loneliness.

  • Syouts

    In my 7th grade science class, I use the last week constructively- both scientific and socially. Rather than show movies or let them have free days, which is what they expect (from experience in other classes, honestly), I posed a rube-goldberg design challenge.  Every minute of science the last week was spent doing science- designing under constraints, testing, predicting, redesigning, and learning from mistakes- with their friends, and the very last day we held our competition.  It was very engaging, easy for the teacher (they brought junk supplies from home, and no notes or papers to grade), fun for the kids, and made the principal happy!  We did not waste a minute!

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »

Education